Friday, November 21, 2014

Seeing the Savage in Dream Boy

There are many comparisons that can be made when analyzing both Dream Boy and Salvage the Bones. The two main characters in both books will be the easiest comparison to make. Esch in Salvage the Bones is a young girl who is finding herself while hiding a major secret, Esch's secret being that she is pregnant. She also escapes to a fantasy world that is composed of stories of greek mythology. Dream Boy on the other hand focuses on Nathan, a young boy that is discovering himself and his sexuality, while hiding a major secret, Nathan's being that he is gay. However it is not his only secret Nathan also keeps the fact that he being molested by his father a secret as well. Nathan escapes the reality of his situation by putting on a facade in front of others. Both Nathan and Esch are in "relationships" with people that are unhealthy for them. Esch finds solace in Manny in Salvage, while Nathan has Roy. Both of their respective love interests put on dual facades depending on who is with them.

Manny does not seem to feel real emotion for Esch outside of things being sexual between them. Whenever Manny and Esch are around people, Manny does not pay Esch any type of special attention. During the instances when they are alone, Manny treats Esch differently, he still keeps her at a distance but is physically intimate with her, resulting in Esch's pregnancy which is what keeps the two tied together. Roy, on the other hand, seems to care about Nathan a bit more than Manny cared about Esch, but still puts on a dual facade depending on who he is with. Around his friends, Roy treats Nathan just like another friend. Yet when they are alone, they also share physical intimacy and their secret of both being gay keeps them tied together. Both Manny and Roy have significant others outside of their relationships with Esch and Nathan respectively. Just comparing the protagonists of these two tales barely scratches the surface of the similarities between the two.

Southern Gothic Style



Both Dream Boy and A Streetcar Named Desire are children of Southern Gothic literature. They emerge from the rich, dark shadowy woods of Southern Gothic Literature, allowing us to examine the ‘values’ of the American South. The characters disrupt the perfect image of the South by bringing a sense of loneliness, lost dreams, and their own haunted world.  The sense of the slowing or stopping of the passage of time follows the characters throughout the book and indeed time has stopped for them as a result of their traumatic experiences of the past. Both Blanche and Nathan are strangers in strange places struggling to find connections to the world. They, the pivotal characters, are set apart from the norm by eccentricities.   Blanche is an aging Southern Belle who lives in a reality of her choosing to escape her looming sad reality and Nathan has moved to a small Southern town, where being gay is definitely not understood or accepted, with a suitcase of dark memories.  

Fate proves to be a prison for both characters. Blanche is a prisoner of the dark past, the memory of her boyfriend’s death, she’s a tortured prisoner of Stanley Kowalski who conspires to bring her to ruins, and finally, she is physically imprisoned when taken away to a mental institution. Nate is a prisoner to his memories of abuse and molestation by his dad; he’s also a prisoner of feelings that he can’t freely express.  Violence is a prevalent theme in both books. Nathan deals with violence at the hands of his dad and of Burke, who almost kills him. Nathan faces his greatest demons in the haunted woods of the South.  Blanche is cornered and raped by Stanley.  Both characters find themselves in a place where they are hoping to find refuge from their ghosts but they end up at the fore-front of war in what was supposed to be the place of escape. In both books there is a tragic past and the ending remains true to the tragedy; there is no sweet ending to soothe the wounds of the past. The reader will not be allowed to walk away easily forgetting the grisly messages that are so obviously manifest in these stories.  The dark, sad song of broken dreams, and souls, and bodies, and the vulgar truth about what lies beneath society’s guise lingers with the reader. 

Thursday, November 20, 2014

Spreading Awareness about Urban Violence

Tonight myself and the rest of LUCAP put on a vigil to spread awareness about street violence in New Orleans. The service was held at St. Anna's Episcopal Church on Esplanade, and was led by Fr. William Terry. Father Bill has become such an inspiration to me over the past month of constant emailing and meetings. Since 2007 he has been documenting the victims of street violence in New Orleans, and is a father and supporter of the people in Treme and around the city. Students from Loyola gathered, heard first hand stories, and paid their respects to those who have fallen. It was amazing to feel the community of students come together and not only become aware to what is happening, but also to find a passion to do good. Father Bill reminded us that we all have talent, and we all have the ability to make a difference. It was a truly moving experience, and I hope to see students rise against urban violence.

Relationships through this semester

Dream Boy has been my favorite book this semester. I have loved reading how people have different experienced with growing up in the south, and yet so similar. The three books we read this semester had a lot to do with unhealthy sexual relationships. Manny and Esch in Salvage the Bones, Blanche all just about all of her sexual past in A Streetcar Named Desire, and the relationship between Nathan and his father and sometimes the relationship between Nathan and Roy in Dream Boy. Each of these relationships have shaped these characters in different ways; Esch's relationship with Manny was unhealthy and resulted in unplanned pregnancy, but she came out of it as a much more mature, responsible woman. Blanch didn't come out of any of her relationships as a better person, but we certainly saw how she was effected in the way her mental health went so down hill. And of course, Nathan's relationship with his father made him into a quieter, awkward kid. And his relationship with Roy makes him more nervous ever day.

These relationships shaped these main characters, and sometimes that was for good, and sometimes the opposite. Also, on top of these relationships, each of these characters have to deal with the culture and expectations of living in the south. Whether it's the weather in Salvage the Bones or how conservative and religious people's morals are in Dream Boy. 

Ghosts of the south

Each text that we've read in class this semester is unique in some degree: A Streetcar Named Desire  explored the violence of domestic life in the south, Salvage The Bones illustrated difficulty of familial ties, and Bellocqs Ophelia as well as Dream Boy show the struggle within the outcast. However, all of our readings share two main commonalities: the ghost of the past and the fantastic reality.

Mama in Salvage the Bones never actually appears, but when Esch wanders the woods or when Skeetah tends to Esch's wounds her presence is visibly available. Moreover, as a form of escapism, Esch experiences life in through a mythological filter when she imagines being Medea or Diana as she traverses the woods as if she were sailing with the Argonauts.



Ophelia's reality is also populated with people who are no longer a part of her life. For example, her father, like Mama from Salvage the Bones, never actually appears, but, when she treats with customers,  his commanding and degrading figure is felt by Ophelia. In fact all of the characters in Ophelia's life are only presented to us in old letters and are therefore forever assigned to the past. Therefore Ophelia's present is submerged in the ghost of her past.



Streetcar named Desire, although to a somewhat lesser degree, also deals with the presence of absent characters. Blanche's former husband, although not frequently mentioned, is a tangible being in her life to the point where even the mention of his name sends her reeling.


But Streetcar deals with the dichotomy of fantasy and reality in an equally if not more direct manner than the other texts we've read in class. The most readily available example of this is Blanche's choice to live in a world of "magic" in order to escape her "vulgar" reality.

Dream Boy deals with ghosts from the past in a different manner. Rather than explicitly using any specific characters, Nathan's landscape is haunted by the ghosts of kids who have drowned in rivers and plantation owners who lost their heads. W

However, Dream Boy addresses the fantasy world directly. This is made especially clear at the end of the novel when Nathan returns to town to find Roy after Burke has raped and assaulted him. Because it is not explicitly clear whether or not Nathan survived the attack, the conclusion of the novel can be seen as Nathan becoming completely engulfed in a separate reality.

Victimization in Dream Boy

 A lot of parallels can be drawn between the Dream Boy and A Streetcar Named Desire, but the strongest of these parallels is that the two have almost the same tragic ending. In A Streetcar Named Desire, Stanley rapes Blanche in a show of grotesquely masculine dominance. In Dream Boy, after Nathan and Roy are discovered in an intimate position, Burke rapes Nathan in the attic of the plantation house. After Stanley rapes Blanche, she reverts almost completely into her dream world; she is taken to a mental institution where she is likely lobotomized. After Nathan is raped, Burke cracks his skull with the arm of a chair. I noticed a parallel here between the ultimate fates of the two: both end up with holes in their skulls. Neither is definitely fatal; Blanche would have survived the lobotomy, though mentally broken. Though it is unclear whether Nathan survives his injuries or finds Roy as a ghost of some sort. The hole in the skull, on a surface level, is the last piece of the Southern Gothic formula: people who live their lives outside the parameters of society are punished for it in the end. 

            A common element in both rapes is that they are seen by the perpetrator as justified because of the sexual past of the victim. For Blanche, Stanley considered the rape to be justified because of Blanche’s promiscuity. Burke sees the rape as justified because he knows that Nathan and Roy have a sexual relationship. Nathan notes “it is as if he deserves it, as if both he and Burke understand that he is made for this use” (172).

Opposing Characteristics

In comparison to Blanche from A Streetcar Named Desire, Nathan's dad from Dream Boy creates this preferable, secondary self image for himself just as Blanche creates for herself as well. As we know, from reading A Streetcar Named Desire, Blanche is a delusional wreck that convincingly lures everyone around her to believe her own made up stories. As for Nathan's dad, we know he's a sinful man, but for outsiders he's a firm believer of God and an avid church goer. Both characters hide from the true grit of their reality. Blanche and Nathan's dad hold many similarities to cope with the ugly truth. Blanche never ceases the chance to add a spill of alcohol to any beverage, and Nathan's dad similarly drinks on the norm, except for Sundays, on the holy day. A difference between the two characters is the arguable fact that Blanche is more harmful to herself while living in a lie, and Nathan's dad is a harmful person to his own family where even his son, Nathan, is terribly afraid of him, where as characters like Stanley encourage Blanche's vulnerability. Both characters hold opposing identities of themselves that create trouble for other characters. Blanche's ways of high maintenance and low self-esteem renders Stanley to go mad, creating conflict for him and his wife, Stella. The actions done by Nathan's father scares Nathan away, but his wife refuses to see the truth, and ignores what harm Nathan's dad can have on the family. The traits that both Nathan's dad and Blanche have drives the reader's interest while reading both stories. Each story's purpose could not have been as wholesome if the characteristics of Nathan's dad and Blanche had not been so deeply twisted.