There are many comparisons that can be made when analyzing both Dream Boy and Salvage the Bones. The two main characters in both books will be the easiest comparison to make. Esch in Salvage the Bones is a young girl who is finding herself while hiding a major secret, Esch's secret being that she is pregnant. She also escapes to a fantasy world that is composed of stories of greek mythology. Dream Boy on the other hand focuses on Nathan, a young boy that is discovering himself and his sexuality, while hiding a major secret, Nathan's being that he is gay. However it is not his only secret Nathan also keeps the fact that he being molested by his father a secret as well. Nathan escapes the reality of his situation by putting on a facade in front of others. Both Nathan and Esch are in "relationships" with people that are unhealthy for them. Esch finds solace in Manny in Salvage, while Nathan has Roy. Both of their respective love interests put on dual facades depending on who is with them.
Manny does not seem to feel real emotion for Esch outside of things being sexual between them. Whenever Manny and Esch are around people, Manny does not pay Esch any type of special attention. During the instances when they are alone, Manny treats Esch differently, he still keeps her at a distance but is physically intimate with her, resulting in Esch's pregnancy which is what keeps the two tied together. Roy, on the other hand, seems to care about Nathan a bit more than Manny cared about Esch, but still puts on a dual facade depending on who he is with. Around his friends, Roy treats Nathan just like another friend. Yet when they are alone, they also share physical intimacy and their secret of both being gay keeps them tied together. Both Manny and Roy have significant others outside of their relationships with Esch and Nathan respectively. Just comparing the protagonists of these two tales barely scratches the surface of the similarities between the two.
Friday, November 21, 2014
Southern Gothic Style
Both Dream Boy and A
Streetcar Named Desire are children of Southern Gothic literature. They emerge
from the rich, dark shadowy woods of Southern Gothic Literature, allowing us to
examine the ‘values’ of the American South. The characters disrupt the perfect
image of the South by bringing a sense of loneliness, lost dreams, and their
own haunted world. The sense of the
slowing or stopping of the passage of time follows the characters throughout
the book and indeed time has stopped for them as a result of their traumatic
experiences of the past. Both Blanche and Nathan are strangers in strange
places struggling to find connections to the world. They, the pivotal
characters, are set apart from the norm by eccentricities. Blanche
is an aging Southern Belle who lives in a reality of her choosing to escape her
looming sad reality and Nathan has moved to a small Southern town, where being
gay is definitely not understood or accepted, with a suitcase of dark memories.
Fate proves to be a prison for both characters.
Blanche is a prisoner of the dark past, the memory of her boyfriend’s death,
she’s a tortured prisoner of Stanley Kowalski who conspires to bring her to
ruins, and finally, she is physically imprisoned when taken away to a mental
institution. Nate is a prisoner to his memories of abuse and molestation by his
dad; he’s also a prisoner of feelings that he can’t freely express. Violence is a prevalent theme in both books.
Nathan deals with violence at the hands of his dad and of Burke, who almost
kills him. Nathan faces his greatest demons in the haunted woods of the South. Blanche is cornered and raped by Stanley. Both characters find themselves in a place
where they are hoping to find refuge from their ghosts but they end up at the
fore-front of war in what was supposed to be the place of escape. In both books
there is a tragic past and the ending remains true to the tragedy; there is no
sweet ending to soothe the wounds of the past. The reader will not be allowed
to walk away easily forgetting the grisly messages that are so obviously
manifest in these stories. The dark, sad
song of broken dreams, and souls, and bodies, and the vulgar truth about what
lies beneath society’s guise lingers with the reader.
Thursday, November 20, 2014
Spreading Awareness about Urban Violence
Tonight myself and the rest of LUCAP put on a vigil to spread awareness about street violence in New Orleans. The service was held at St. Anna's Episcopal Church on Esplanade, and was led by Fr. William Terry. Father Bill has become such an inspiration to me over the past month of constant emailing and meetings. Since 2007 he has been documenting the victims of street violence in New Orleans, and is a father and supporter of the people in Treme and around the city. Students from Loyola gathered, heard first hand stories, and paid their respects to those who have fallen. It was amazing to feel the community of students come together and not only become aware to what is happening, but also to find a passion to do good. Father Bill reminded us that we all have talent, and we all have the ability to make a difference. It was a truly moving experience, and I hope to see students rise against urban violence.
Relationships through this semester
Dream Boy has been my favorite book this semester. I have loved reading how people have different experienced with growing up in the south, and yet so similar. The three books we read this semester had a lot to do with unhealthy sexual relationships. Manny and Esch in Salvage the Bones, Blanche all just about all of her sexual past in A Streetcar Named Desire, and the relationship between Nathan and his father and sometimes the relationship between Nathan and Roy in Dream Boy. Each of these relationships have shaped these characters in different ways; Esch's relationship with Manny was unhealthy and resulted in unplanned pregnancy, but she came out of it as a much more mature, responsible woman. Blanch didn't come out of any of her relationships as a better person, but we certainly saw how she was effected in the way her mental health went so down hill. And of course, Nathan's relationship with his father made him into a quieter, awkward kid. And his relationship with Roy makes him more nervous ever day.
These relationships shaped these main characters, and sometimes that was for good, and sometimes the opposite. Also, on top of these relationships, each of these characters have to deal with the culture and expectations of living in the south. Whether it's the weather in Salvage the Bones or how conservative and religious people's morals are in Dream Boy.
These relationships shaped these main characters, and sometimes that was for good, and sometimes the opposite. Also, on top of these relationships, each of these characters have to deal with the culture and expectations of living in the south. Whether it's the weather in Salvage the Bones or how conservative and religious people's morals are in Dream Boy.
Ghosts of the south
Each text that we've read in class this semester is unique in some degree: A Streetcar Named Desire explored the violence of domestic life in the south, Salvage The Bones illustrated difficulty of familial ties, and Bellocqs Ophelia as well as Dream Boy show the struggle within the outcast. However, all of our readings share two main commonalities: the ghost of the past and the fantastic reality.
Mama in Salvage the Bones never actually appears, but when Esch wanders the woods or when Skeetah tends to Esch's wounds her presence is visibly available. Moreover, as a form of escapism, Esch experiences life in through a mythological filter when she imagines being Medea or Diana as she traverses the woods as if she were sailing with the Argonauts.
Ophelia's reality is also populated with people who are no longer a part of her life. For example, her father, like Mama from Salvage the Bones, never actually appears, but, when she treats with customers, his commanding and degrading figure is felt by Ophelia. In fact all of the characters in Ophelia's life are only presented to us in old letters and are therefore forever assigned to the past. Therefore Ophelia's present is submerged in the ghost of her past.
Streetcar named Desire, although to a somewhat lesser degree, also deals with the presence of absent characters. Blanche's former husband, although not frequently mentioned, is a tangible being in her life to the point where even the mention of his name sends her reeling.
But Streetcar deals with the dichotomy of fantasy and reality in an equally if not more direct manner than the other texts we've read in class. The most readily available example of this is Blanche's choice to live in a world of "magic" in order to escape her "vulgar" reality.
Dream Boy deals with ghosts from the past in a different manner. Rather than explicitly using any specific characters, Nathan's landscape is haunted by the ghosts of kids who have drowned in rivers and plantation owners who lost their heads. W
However, Dream Boy addresses the fantasy world directly. This is made especially clear at the end of the novel when Nathan returns to town to find Roy after Burke has raped and assaulted him. Because it is not explicitly clear whether or not Nathan survived the attack, the conclusion of the novel can be seen as Nathan becoming completely engulfed in a separate reality.
Mama in Salvage the Bones never actually appears, but when Esch wanders the woods or when Skeetah tends to Esch's wounds her presence is visibly available. Moreover, as a form of escapism, Esch experiences life in through a mythological filter when she imagines being Medea or Diana as she traverses the woods as if she were sailing with the Argonauts.
Ophelia's reality is also populated with people who are no longer a part of her life. For example, her father, like Mama from Salvage the Bones, never actually appears, but, when she treats with customers, his commanding and degrading figure is felt by Ophelia. In fact all of the characters in Ophelia's life are only presented to us in old letters and are therefore forever assigned to the past. Therefore Ophelia's present is submerged in the ghost of her past.
Streetcar named Desire, although to a somewhat lesser degree, also deals with the presence of absent characters. Blanche's former husband, although not frequently mentioned, is a tangible being in her life to the point where even the mention of his name sends her reeling.
But Streetcar deals with the dichotomy of fantasy and reality in an equally if not more direct manner than the other texts we've read in class. The most readily available example of this is Blanche's choice to live in a world of "magic" in order to escape her "vulgar" reality.
Dream Boy deals with ghosts from the past in a different manner. Rather than explicitly using any specific characters, Nathan's landscape is haunted by the ghosts of kids who have drowned in rivers and plantation owners who lost their heads. W
However, Dream Boy addresses the fantasy world directly. This is made especially clear at the end of the novel when Nathan returns to town to find Roy after Burke has raped and assaulted him. Because it is not explicitly clear whether or not Nathan survived the attack, the conclusion of the novel can be seen as Nathan becoming completely engulfed in a separate reality.
Victimization in Dream Boy
A lot of parallels can be drawn
between the Dream Boy and A Streetcar Named Desire, but the
strongest of these parallels is that the two have almost the same tragic
ending. In A Streetcar Named Desire,
Stanley rapes Blanche in a show of grotesquely masculine dominance. In Dream Boy, after Nathan and Roy are
discovered in an intimate position, Burke rapes Nathan in the attic of the
plantation house. After Stanley rapes Blanche, she reverts almost completely
into her dream world; she is taken to a mental institution where she is likely lobotomized.
After Nathan is raped, Burke cracks his skull with the arm of a chair. I
noticed a parallel here between the ultimate fates of the two: both end up with
holes in their skulls. Neither is definitely fatal; Blanche would have survived
the lobotomy, though mentally broken. Though it is unclear whether Nathan survives
his injuries or finds Roy as a ghost of some sort. The hole in the skull, on a
surface level, is the last piece of the Southern Gothic formula: people who
live their lives outside the parameters of society are punished for it in the
end.
A common element in both rapes is
that they are seen by the perpetrator as justified because of the sexual past
of the victim. For Blanche, Stanley considered the rape to be justified because
of Blanche’s promiscuity. Burke sees the rape as justified because he knows that
Nathan and Roy have a sexual relationship. Nathan notes “it is as if he deserves
it, as if both he and Burke understand that he is made for this use” (172).
Opposing Characteristics
In comparison to Blanche from A Streetcar Named Desire, Nathan's dad from Dream Boy creates this preferable, secondary self image for himself just as Blanche creates for herself as well. As we know, from reading A Streetcar Named Desire, Blanche is a delusional wreck that convincingly lures everyone around her to believe her own made up stories. As for Nathan's dad, we know he's a sinful man, but for outsiders he's a firm believer of God and an avid church goer. Both characters hide from the true grit of their reality. Blanche and Nathan's dad hold many similarities to cope with the ugly truth. Blanche never ceases the chance to add a spill of alcohol to any beverage, and Nathan's dad similarly drinks on the norm, except for Sundays, on the holy day. A difference between the two characters is the arguable fact that Blanche is more harmful to herself while living in a lie, and Nathan's dad is a harmful person to his own family where even his son, Nathan, is terribly afraid of him, where as characters like Stanley encourage Blanche's vulnerability. Both characters hold opposing identities of themselves that create trouble for other characters. Blanche's ways of high maintenance and low self-esteem renders Stanley to go mad, creating conflict for him and his wife, Stella. The actions done by Nathan's father scares Nathan away, but his wife refuses to see the truth, and ignores what harm Nathan's dad can have on the family. The traits that both Nathan's dad and Blanche have drives the reader's interest while reading both stories. Each story's purpose could not have been as wholesome if the characteristics of Nathan's dad and Blanche had not been so deeply twisted.
Vigil Against Street Violence
As a member of LUCAP eboard I helped with putting together this event and it turned out very well. We wanted to raise awareness of the street violence in New Orleans and make Loyola students see how often people in our neighborhood are killed and how much it affects our community. This has a lot to do with our class subject. Salvage the bones is a very good example of how poverty can affect how a child is brought up. We see them fighting dogs, fighting themselves, an alcoholic father, and young pregnancy. There were some kids from the Anna's Arts for Kids program and they are being affected currently by having to grow up in these bad areas. They are in failing schools and it is much harder for them socially and economically to have good opportunities. It also shows that racism and many other issues we've talked about in class are still very prevalent in today's society. I'm currently reading Jesmyn Ward's "Men We Reaped" which is a memoir about the many young black men she has known that were murdered. When I went to see Jesmyn Ward speak she talked about how the place to start with fixing these issues is discussion and tat is what we aimed for at the vigil: acknowledging these issues and bringing it to the attention of the more fortunate members of the community. I learned a lot from the multiple speakers and Father Bill who was the leader of the ceremony said we all have power to help resolve this issue. He said it's the process of helping things progress rather than trying to fix everything all at once. He also makes a yearly murder board for New Orleans which made the problem and people affected very real. Overall it was a great and powerful experience and connected back to this class very well.
The victims: Blanche and Nathan
Blanche from A Streetcar Named Desire and Nathan have many of the same obstacles even though their characters are very different. Both are raped and must decide if they are to tell what has happened to them or not. For Blanche she does tell and ends up in a mental asylum, so for her telling the truth didn't seem to end up being the "right choice." For Nathan he has not told and is also keeping his sexuality a secret but it is not helping him either because he is stuck with his family; his father who is the abuser and his mother who stands by and does not help or abuses by neglecting him. Also, both Blanche and Nathan are financially dependent on their abusers. Nathan who is a minor will have nowhere to turn unless he does out his abuser. While, Blanche has brought herself to financial ruin and comes to seek the help of her sister and by default Stanley. They are in different time periods as well as opposite genders which also affects how they will be treated. Both although victims can be seen as at fault or bad victims. Blanche is also a perpetrator herself on young boys so it is hard to sympathize with her. Nathan, because he lives in such a religious and small town and is gay, could be exposed and seen as also taking part in these sinful acts or deserving it. It is interesting that their stories are so different but they struggle with the same things.
Today's Vigil
Today at St. Anna's Episcopal Church, Liza organized an amazing vigil against urban violence. We took a bus to the church, and were greeted by Rev. William Terry. Rev. Terry lead us through prayers honoring those who have fallen victim to urban violence, and we sang hymns together. He spoke on his personal experiences in the area of the ruthless crimes he has witnessed, but also had three children, and a mother whose son was a victim of the violence speak. The children told stories of their experiences living in the neighborhood, and what their dreams were for the future.
The whole congregation was very moving. There was a strong sense of community and will to find ways to keep the coming generations out of the seemingly endless cycle of urban violence.
The vigil ended with a candle-lighting, and the names of those who passed were read aloud and honored.
Stella & Nathan's Mom
When looking at Williams' "A Streetcar Named Desire", and Grimsley's "Dream Boy", there are several common themes. One of the most prominent shared themes is the similarity of Stella and Nathan's mom's roles as enablers.
In "A Streetcar Named Desire", Stella is described as weak almost. She knows that Stanley's abuse is wrong, but chooses not to do anything about it. She knows that he loathes Blanche, but she chooses to still believe him over her when the rape is committed because it is easier. She chooses to remain ignorant of his actions because it will not disrupt the life that she has grown accustomed to living
In "Dream Boy", Nathan's mom plays the same role. She is described by Nathan as being invisible. She knows very well what goes on between her son and her husband, but makes a choice not to do anything about it because it would mean uprooting the life she has grown comfortable with. She instead allows it to happen, without stepping in and saving her son from a disgusting situation.
Both are enablers. They understand that the weaker party needs help and someone to stand up for them, but they are too worried about what their support would mean for them. Their support would likely change the situation they've grown comfortable in. They would lose the figure that they rely on for support, their husbands.
In "A Streetcar Named Desire", Stella is described as weak almost. She knows that Stanley's abuse is wrong, but chooses not to do anything about it. She knows that he loathes Blanche, but she chooses to still believe him over her when the rape is committed because it is easier. She chooses to remain ignorant of his actions because it will not disrupt the life that she has grown accustomed to living
In "Dream Boy", Nathan's mom plays the same role. She is described by Nathan as being invisible. She knows very well what goes on between her son and her husband, but makes a choice not to do anything about it because it would mean uprooting the life she has grown comfortable with. She instead allows it to happen, without stepping in and saving her son from a disgusting situation.
Both are enablers. They understand that the weaker party needs help and someone to stand up for them, but they are too worried about what their support would mean for them. Their support would likely change the situation they've grown comfortable in. They would lose the figure that they rely on for support, their husbands.
A History of Violence
Comparing aspects from Jim Grimsley's Dream Boy and Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire.
What stood out the most to me in my reading of Grimsley's novel in relation to the other works we've read this semester was the similarities between Burke and Stanley, from Williams' Streetcar.
Throughout each work, both Burke and Stanley both have a sense of underlying, simmering violence in their characterizations, which is displayed in a few different ways.
Both Burke and Stanley have suspicion towards each work's respective protagonist and their true nature, or the secrets they may have.
They both carry out threatening behavior towards the protagonists - Burke holds Nathan off a bridge above a river, threatening to drop him when he cant swim, and Stanley uncovers Blanche's sexual past, ruining the semblance of a life she has established for herself in New Orleans.
Both Burke and Stanley have explosive displays of violence - Burke throws Randy around, who remarks, "You always try to hurt somebody," (Grimsley, 132), which Burke eventually does, beating Nathan to death(?), as described, "as if he wants to make Nathan hurt," (Grimsley, 173). Stanley has instances of physical abuse towards his pregnant wife Stella, whom he hits.
Both Burke and Stanley display a sort of hypermasculinity within each work, which is perhaps a form of compensation for their own faults. Burke repeatedly asks after Roy's girlfriend Evelyn, and goes so far as to flaunt himself, taking off his shirt and displaying himself in the most primal way physically, asserting his masculinity. Stanley almost seems hyperbolic in his masculine characterization with displays of violence, hobbies, loudness, distrust towards Blanche (an unusual woman), and his own history - first as a veteran and then secondarily as an immigrant, which serves to alienate him as an American male, which he perhaps makes up for in a caricaturistic manner. Williams' stresses Stanley's character to make a statement about masculine behavior.
Most potently, the similarity between Burke and Stanley stems from their acts of rape within the works. Burke, who before hinted at a homoerotic subtext, bursts forth with an aggressive display of repressed sexuality upon Nathan, taking out not only his sexuality upon him, but also delivers an immense act of violence in beating him either to death or somewhere quite near it. Stanley, who has struggled to suppress Blanche's disruption of his way of life, finally acts out towards her in a catalystic way in reaction to her flirtations and seductive behavior, turning it around on her in an act of sexual violence. Both Burke and Stanley violently rip choice away from their victims, both having preyed upon them throughout the course of the works in a subtle but intent way, which finally comes to a head through an extremely savage act.
(Also as an unrelated side note - a thought I just had: the presence or idea of plantation homes and how they function in both works is very interesting. In Dream Boy, obviously the "haunted" plantation home, and then in Streetcar, the loss of Belle Reve. When reflecting on each text, the plantation house can be symbolic of a loss of, or a dilapidation of the ideals of the Old South, especially when considering how both works focus on a kind of new sexuality - either a normalcy of homosexuality or assertive female sexuality.)
What stood out the most to me in my reading of Grimsley's novel in relation to the other works we've read this semester was the similarities between Burke and Stanley, from Williams' Streetcar.
Throughout each work, both Burke and Stanley both have a sense of underlying, simmering violence in their characterizations, which is displayed in a few different ways.
Both Burke and Stanley have suspicion towards each work's respective protagonist and their true nature, or the secrets they may have.
They both carry out threatening behavior towards the protagonists - Burke holds Nathan off a bridge above a river, threatening to drop him when he cant swim, and Stanley uncovers Blanche's sexual past, ruining the semblance of a life she has established for herself in New Orleans.
Both Burke and Stanley have explosive displays of violence - Burke throws Randy around, who remarks, "You always try to hurt somebody," (Grimsley, 132), which Burke eventually does, beating Nathan to death(?), as described, "as if he wants to make Nathan hurt," (Grimsley, 173). Stanley has instances of physical abuse towards his pregnant wife Stella, whom he hits.
Both Burke and Stanley display a sort of hypermasculinity within each work, which is perhaps a form of compensation for their own faults. Burke repeatedly asks after Roy's girlfriend Evelyn, and goes so far as to flaunt himself, taking off his shirt and displaying himself in the most primal way physically, asserting his masculinity. Stanley almost seems hyperbolic in his masculine characterization with displays of violence, hobbies, loudness, distrust towards Blanche (an unusual woman), and his own history - first as a veteran and then secondarily as an immigrant, which serves to alienate him as an American male, which he perhaps makes up for in a caricaturistic manner. Williams' stresses Stanley's character to make a statement about masculine behavior.
Most potently, the similarity between Burke and Stanley stems from their acts of rape within the works. Burke, who before hinted at a homoerotic subtext, bursts forth with an aggressive display of repressed sexuality upon Nathan, taking out not only his sexuality upon him, but also delivers an immense act of violence in beating him either to death or somewhere quite near it. Stanley, who has struggled to suppress Blanche's disruption of his way of life, finally acts out towards her in a catalystic way in reaction to her flirtations and seductive behavior, turning it around on her in an act of sexual violence. Both Burke and Stanley violently rip choice away from their victims, both having preyed upon them throughout the course of the works in a subtle but intent way, which finally comes to a head through an extremely savage act.
![]() |
| Decrepit plantation home with lots of moonlight and darkness and clouds, like in Grimsley's Dream Boy |
(Also as an unrelated side note - a thought I just had: the presence or idea of plantation homes and how they function in both works is very interesting. In Dream Boy, obviously the "haunted" plantation home, and then in Streetcar, the loss of Belle Reve. When reflecting on each text, the plantation house can be symbolic of a loss of, or a dilapidation of the ideals of the Old South, especially when considering how both works focus on a kind of new sexuality - either a normalcy of homosexuality or assertive female sexuality.)
Reflection
Jim Grimsley's "Dream Boy" is captivating. The novel brings in so many forbidden elements that the reader can't put the book down. It is filled with suspense, from Nathan's fathers mysterious past, to the lingering tension that constantly fills the space between Nathan and Roy.
Nathan's family's past is filled with unknown variables. It is never outwardly said but we can very obviously infer that Nathan's father molests him. His mother is an enabler. She is invisible, and does not do anything to stop his father. It leave the reader on constant edge, wondering when and if it will happen again, and how it will effect his relationship with Roy. Personally, I want to know why they keep moving. Did people find out what goes on in their house?
Roy and Nathan bring a new twist on the classic tale of forbidden love. Their role as secretly gay lovers in the south captivate the audience. Combined with Roy's constant anxiety that someone may find them out, Nathan's issues that have arisen from his relationship with his dad are overwhelming. Roy flip-flops everyday. One day he seems to be totally devoted and in love with Nathan, and then he goes to completely ignoring him.
Nathan's family's past is filled with unknown variables. It is never outwardly said but we can very obviously infer that Nathan's father molests him. His mother is an enabler. She is invisible, and does not do anything to stop his father. It leave the reader on constant edge, wondering when and if it will happen again, and how it will effect his relationship with Roy. Personally, I want to know why they keep moving. Did people find out what goes on in their house?
Roy and Nathan bring a new twist on the classic tale of forbidden love. Their role as secretly gay lovers in the south captivate the audience. Combined with Roy's constant anxiety that someone may find them out, Nathan's issues that have arisen from his relationship with his dad are overwhelming. Roy flip-flops everyday. One day he seems to be totally devoted and in love with Nathan, and then he goes to completely ignoring him.
Fergusons Across America
After attending the panel discussion about the situation in Ferguson, Missouri put on by Ms. Boyett on Tuesday, I feel like I have a much broader understanding of the issues. Each of the six speakers shared there opinions on different aspects of the situation resulting in a well rounded, incredibly informational discussion addressing all the "whys" that have arisen after the shooting.
My favorite speaker discussed why violence is an issue in the first place. People are not violent because of their color, people are violent because of the imbalance that plagues our society. I couldn't agree with her more. Individuals act out when they feel like they aren't receiving the dignity they deserve, which is what is currently happening in Ferguson. Both the victims and the activists deserve respect, and they deserve to be heard - not just shut down. We need balance in our society, and we need the return of community.
Another one of my favorites from the panel discussed the huge role social media has played in unfolding the injustices happening in Ferguson. It has facilitated open speaking, and non censored discussion. People are able to get news from sources in the area themselves, without the filters and distortion the media often puts forth. The case has gotten worldwide support from the global community thanks the speed on the internet.
I also thought what the police chief had to say was interesting. He highlighted the manipulation through misinformation occurring in major media outlets. It had become a race for stations to release the story first, not release a reliable story, and people are believing media distortion to be the absolute truth.
Now the question is what do we need to do as a community now to help prevent cases drowning in injustice, as is happening currently in Missouri.
My favorite speaker discussed why violence is an issue in the first place. People are not violent because of their color, people are violent because of the imbalance that plagues our society. I couldn't agree with her more. Individuals act out when they feel like they aren't receiving the dignity they deserve, which is what is currently happening in Ferguson. Both the victims and the activists deserve respect, and they deserve to be heard - not just shut down. We need balance in our society, and we need the return of community.
Another one of my favorites from the panel discussed the huge role social media has played in unfolding the injustices happening in Ferguson. It has facilitated open speaking, and non censored discussion. People are able to get news from sources in the area themselves, without the filters and distortion the media often puts forth. The case has gotten worldwide support from the global community thanks the speed on the internet.
I also thought what the police chief had to say was interesting. He highlighted the manipulation through misinformation occurring in major media outlets. It had become a race for stations to release the story first, not release a reliable story, and people are believing media distortion to be the absolute truth.
Now the question is what do we need to do as a community now to help prevent cases drowning in injustice, as is happening currently in Missouri.
Tradition, Troubles, and Disapproval
Dream Boy by Jim Grimsley and Salvage the Bones by Jesmyn Ward have a lot of similarities between the characters and their explanation on the views of the south. More specifically, I would like to focus on the similar characteristics between the characters in Dream Boy and the characters of the Batiste family in Salvage the Bones. Both books show a strong sexual tension between specific characters, and this has a great deal to do with the strong secrecy in their relationships. Secrecy is portrayed in Salvage the Bones by Esch hiding her pregnancy not only from her father, but from her whole family. In relation to this, Nathan does exactly the same regarding his sexuality. Both Nathan and Esch’s family have to deal with extremely agonizing stereotypes simply because of their relation to the south.
The haunted south has dealt with issues very unethically and immorally during its course of history and many of these characteristics are still present today. With Esch’s family being African-American and Nathan noticing his homosexuality, both will have to cope with the extreme disapproval among traditional white southerners. Further, Esch’s father and Nathan’s mother both have extremely similar attributes. Esch’s father is not truly there for his children ever since their mother passed, and Nathan’s mother acts as a bystander regarding her knowing of her son’s sexual molestation from his father. The troubles that both of these families have gone through would make living under those circumstances unimaginable. Domestic violence is something that will never be completely vanished, and both of these novels do a great job describing some of the different aspects of domestic violence.
Guardian Angels
Characters in the novels Salvage the Bones and Dream Boy can relate to each other; more notably, Nathan's mother and Skeetah. Both of these characters seem to be withdrawn from the rest of their family. Skeetah spends most of his time with his dog, China, instead of with the rest of his family. In comparison, Nathan's mother spends majority of her time by herself in her house. She attempts to steer relatively clear of Nathan and her husband.
Both Nathan's mother and Skeetah are intuitive characters. For example, Skeetah figures out that Esch is pregnant long before anyone else finds out, and before she tells anyone. Nathan's mother is similar because she knows about Nathan's father and how he treats him. Also, in the novel, there are several implications of her knowledge about Nathan and Roy's relationship.
Even though they seem withdrawn from their families, they still care about them. Skeetah is always caring for China, but the second that esch our anyone else is in trouble, he is quick to come to their aid. Nathan's mother can relate because she still helps out Nathan by trying to steer him away from good father, giving him food when he tries to avoid the house, and letting him leave the house to get away from father.
These two characters are silent guardian angels. They may be distant on the outside, but on the inside, they would give up anything to help their loved ones.
Both Nathan's mother and Skeetah are intuitive characters. For example, Skeetah figures out that Esch is pregnant long before anyone else finds out, and before she tells anyone. Nathan's mother is similar because she knows about Nathan's father and how he treats him. Also, in the novel, there are several implications of her knowledge about Nathan and Roy's relationship.
Even though they seem withdrawn from their families, they still care about them. Skeetah is always caring for China, but the second that esch our anyone else is in trouble, he is quick to come to their aid. Nathan's mother can relate because she still helps out Nathan by trying to steer him away from good father, giving him food when he tries to avoid the house, and letting him leave the house to get away from father.
These two characters are silent guardian angels. They may be distant on the outside, but on the inside, they would give up anything to help their loved ones.
Wednesday, November 19, 2014
Haunted Dreams
In Dream Boy, there is a foreshadowing of frightening things to come and many references to death and hauntings. Nathan and Roy keep many secrets from each other and these secrets are always lurking and lingering in dark places.
Roy is sexually haunted by inner struggles of social conformity. Society tells Roy that he should like girls, however, he is in love with another boy. Roy's outbursts are reminiscent of someone who is possessed by a demon. There is something dark inside of Roy as seen by his violent outbursts with Nathan.
Nathan has been sleeping in the woods near the cemetery because that's where he feels the safest. The branches and leaves of the woods provide him protection from his father. Nathan is constantly haunted by his dad and what his dad has done. Nathan goes to the cemetery to "rest in peace," which may be a sign of foreboding suicide.
In Salvage the Bones, the imminent danger is the hurricane and the reader always knows that it's approaching. While there is fear of the impending doom, the "what" of the fear is known. In Dream Boy, the reader has a fear of the unknown. There is a feeling of something lurking or approaching, but no one knows for sure what exactly the catastrophe will be. Salvage the Bones is optimistic in a way because there is an intention to save things--to salvage people, animals, and just life in general. In contrast, Dream Boy is an ironic title. There is nothing dreamy about the story--Nathan and Roy's experiences are more like nightmares. There are motifs of death, like in Salvage, but there are no real signs of or references to life.
Approaching the end of the book, I hope there is some optimistic twist. Even though death seems near, I hope there is something cathartic that comes from all of the sadness is Dream Boy.
Tuesday, November 18, 2014
Sharing the same meaning
From Salvage the Bones up until the current book we are reading now Dream Boy, all show some sort of comparison in a form of domestic violence, as a fellow classmate stated "alcoholism", or some form of masculinity. However, what most caught my eye is how domestic violence is portrayed in Streetcar Named Desire as well as in Dream Boy. Further, in Streetcar Named Desire domestic violence was portrayed between Stanley raping Blanche basically stripping her of any internal dignity she was holding on to. Also Dream Boy shared the form of sexual abuse when the father sexual abuses him but like in Streetcar Named Desire both the boy and Blanche can't really tell anyone there situation because no one will believe them. Although the mother in Dream Boy knows whats going on she brushes it off not believing what went just as how Stella didn't believe Blanche when she was raped by Stanley. Furthermore, both the boy and Blanche where stuck in a situation where the husband in Streetcar Named Desire and the Father in Dream Boy had some sort of control or power of what goes on in their household drawing a form of fear from the woman of the households, with not going against the demands of their husbands. Even though Dream Boy had its own title I believe but Blanche and the little boy in Dream Boy are stuck in a dream realm where reality doesn't make sense and wanting to better themselves is not an option.
Common Themes
He is not the best father. He frequently yells, insults, and intimidates his kids. He provides for his kids the best he can, but emotionally the Batiste children are on their own. Each of the kids take care of each other. Papa is completely oblivious to the problems his family is going through until the hurricane. I find this a form of negligence. Nathan experiences alcoholism, negligence, and abuse as well. He father is an alcoholic and from the beginning readers know something is weird about their relationship. Nathan's father molests him. Nathan's mother ignore everything that happens. She tries her best to stop him, but often she remains quite and timid. She most likely acts this way for her own safety. This makes me wonder how was the mother and father's relationship before Nathan was born, was the dad abusive to the mother, when did the alcoholism and emotional and physical abuse begin? Both books include parents who are addicted to alcohol and some form of neglect and abuse.
Friday, November 14, 2014
Dream Boy
I like this book so far, but it definitely has a dark feeling. I'm really curious to find out why they move so much. We have learned that the father is a drunk creep, but did he get caught? Did something else happen? Why did the family have to move? I think the story, if it wasn't for the homophobic time period, is cute. Roy isn't really great for Nathan, but they definitely are young love. I feel bad for Nathan because he has to constantly figure out what mood Roy is in and does sound emotionally abusive. A few things I'm anticipating is what will happen with the dad, what will happen with Roy's friends when they find out. I wonder if one will be cool about it and the other will be rude. There's a lot of different aspects of this story.
Dream Boy but Not the Only One
The title of the novel is what interests me. Dream boy telling the tale of Nathan and Roy's secretive relationship. It seems that everything that occurs in the book is anything but a dream. They only time that Nathan ever really finds any comfort is when he is with Roy alone. Other than those circumstances, everything is cruel and riddled with heartache. They way Roy treats Nathan when he is in front of his friends is reminiscent of Nathan's father's cruelty. It makes me wonder if Roy and Nathan's father have more in common than Roy and Nathan. It seems maybe Nathan's father is ashamed of how he feels and hides behind the guise of a wife, all the while sexually assaulting his son as that in his mind must be the only real way Nathan's father can express his desires without the world seeing him for what he truly is.
I think that Nathan's father could be a possible future for Roy. And the title blurs the lines between what is real and what is wanted. Typically in a dream world everything will work out for Nathan in the way he wants. However he is surrounded by so much negativity, that the reality of the situation is his sexual orientation will get him ostracized. It seems that Nathan can't count on anyone in the story as when the moment is really crucial no one backs him up. The closest anyone comes to this is his mother, and even she turns a blind eye when things get too heated in their home. Nathan dreams of a better life but doesn't completely buy into the reality of the situation. Whereas it seems Roy accepts his desires, but feels like in order to live in the reality around him, he must conform to the rules. Roy's way brings him far in society and makes him popular but it is likely slowly eating at him inside and could bring him down a bad path that makes him closeted yet violent as he gets older. Nathan , however, will stay in his dream world that may not bring him happiness but will keep him from denying who he is..
I think that Nathan's father could be a possible future for Roy. And the title blurs the lines between what is real and what is wanted. Typically in a dream world everything will work out for Nathan in the way he wants. However he is surrounded by so much negativity, that the reality of the situation is his sexual orientation will get him ostracized. It seems that Nathan can't count on anyone in the story as when the moment is really crucial no one backs him up. The closest anyone comes to this is his mother, and even she turns a blind eye when things get too heated in their home. Nathan dreams of a better life but doesn't completely buy into the reality of the situation. Whereas it seems Roy accepts his desires, but feels like in order to live in the reality around him, he must conform to the rules. Roy's way brings him far in society and makes him popular but it is likely slowly eating at him inside and could bring him down a bad path that makes him closeted yet violent as he gets older. Nathan , however, will stay in his dream world that may not bring him happiness but will keep him from denying who he is..
Response to Dream Boy
Jim Grimsley's novel Dream Boy has very interesting moments where the reading want to continue to read to see what would happen next. Further, what most interested me, is why Roy treat Nathan so badly. Nathan shows Roy nothing but love but Roy has his bipolar moments when one day he wants to be bother than another he gives Nathan the cold shoulder, rejecting his presents. I feel as if Roy is using Nathan, kind of how some married men have secret lives having a same sex lover. In which shows because of Roy has a girlfriend and known to be masculine, but behind closed door he have intercourse with Nathan. Roy is a prime example of how married men who live secret life behind close doors, as one of my classmates stated resembling a script wrote by a famous R&B artist R.Kelly called "Trap in The Closet". I believe Nathan will get fed up with Roy and either cast him out on his secret teenage affair, give Roy a choice its either him or his girlfriend, or just complete give up on Roy and move on.
Personas in Dream Boy
Nathan’s family seems to be haunted by some secret
wherever they go. They keep moving from place to place to try to escape the
truth as soon as people start catching a glimpse of it, but they themselves can’t
escape the truth. Nathan’s dad is always reading and quoting from the Bible and
he’s very attentive in church’. He tries to exude this saintly aura when he’s actually
the devil on Nathan’s back. We don’t get to see what’s going on inside his
head, to trace perhaps a trace of guilt or maybe more sociopathic tendencies.
We see Nathan’s mom in denial of the situation. She
seems to be struggling with burying the truth of the situation. She seems to ignore
or maybe condone her husband’s behavior and instead of being Nathan’s
protector, she warns him to not do anything to trigger his dad and to keep
clear of him. Nathan has to resort to sleeping among tombstones in the cold night
and his mom does nothing to help him, to stand up for him. Her love seems
empty, lacking potential, or any tiny promise of it.
It’s interesting that Nathan is able to feel so
drawn to Roy although his interactions with Roy triggers the image of his
father and brings him face to face with memories he has tried to bury. “The
memory is his father standing in a doorway, in the house in Rose Hill, and it
reminds him of Roy because of the look in his father’s eyes.” Roy acts like a
tough guy and tries to control Nathan but he’s really insecure. He gets jealous
if Nathan has the most innocent conversation with a girl. When he thinks that
Nathan’s had sex with someone before that really upsets him. If Nathan tries to discuss, or imply any
emotional substance between them, he gets upset. It’s as though they are to be
affectionate in a physical manner, and that’s as far as Roy can allow it to go.
Although he’s so into Nathan, he keeps warning Nathan not to tell anyone and
even tells Nathan that he’s not his boyfriend. He says, “I have a girlfriend. And I don’t
need to do this if I don’t want to.” He’s rather mercurial. He seems to be
interested in Nathan as far as it benefits him, but doesn’t really consider
Nathan’s feelings while expecting Nathan to be conscious of his own feelings.
Nathan is undoubtedly alone. His dad is unwell in
body and spirit and the figure of his mom is a vacant shell. He is beginning to
find a likeness of support in Roy who is rather wobbly. I’m anticipating that
Roy will falter under the heavy gaze of society and will be the Judas who
betrays love with a kiss.
Conflicting Feelings
The love in this story seems to me like a roller coaster. Whenever Roy and Nathan find somewhere private and begin to get busy, they both are deeply in love with each other. But the next day, if Nathan says something wrong, or does the tiniest thing that make Roy uncomfortable, he gives Nathan the cold shoulder for little to no reason at all. But then, as they get some time to settle down, Roy starts to treat Nathan good by asking him to hang out and such. So it is primarily Roy who has these up and down feelings for Nathan. Nathan on the other hand, always wants Roy around. He never had conflicting feelings about him. The only times he has given Roy the cold shoulder was when Roy gets in his dark mood phases. Also, during the swimming trip with Roy and his friends, they bring up his girlfriend and Nathan gets very uncomfortable which drives him to being silent in the car. But later that night, they begin to do their thing which recreates that loving feeling between them. But after that, things get awkward between them, and they go home in disappointment. These constant up and down feelings for one another could ultimately lead to the downfall of their relationship.
Thursday, November 13, 2014
The Perks of Being a Dream Boy
The first chapter of Dream Boy is incredibly misleading. It
lulls the reader into a false sense of security about Roy and Nathan and their
relationship. If the book ended on page 17, the reader could just assume that
they lives happily ever after, maintaining the minimum amount of secrecy
necessary to keep them safe in the 1970’s south. One of the beautiful things
about their relationship, especially in the earliest stages, is how well the
two boys communicate non-verbally. They can sense their mutual attraction as
soon as they are close together, and much of their romantic, physical, and
sexual interaction is wordless.
Of course, there is no story without
conflict.
The relationship between Roy and
Nathan has a consistent element of darkness to it. Whenever the two boys head
are mentioned, they are described as skulls, adding an element of death to
their relationship. Their first kiss occurs in a cemetery, and this spot
remains their safe zone for the first few chapters. But even with the
relationship between the boys being under consistent stress, the primary source
of stress in the book is clearly Nathan’s father. Grimsley does an excellent
job of showing the tension and fear that Nathan feels when he knows his fathers’
intentions.
On a different note, the
relationship between Roy and Nathan reminded me of Brad and Patrick (AKA
Nothing) in the book and movie The Perks
of Being a Wallflower. Their relationship has the same elements of secrecy
and on-again off again tension, between an out-crowd boy and a jock with macho
friends. While this relationship was a subplot of Perks, both show the relationships in about the same amount of text. Perks was published in 1999, Dream Boy in 1995. Though the former takes place in the time it was published and the latter takes place twenty years prior, the relationships are written similarly. The main difference is the in Perks is that Patrick tells his friends and Brad doesn't tell his, whereas in Dream Boy nobody knows, but Roy's friends seem to know that Nathan is gay.
protective characters and setting
So far in Dream Boy I've seen a lot of connection to Salvage the Bones. Mainly parallels between Esch and Nathan and Skeetah and Nathan's mom. There is impending doom in both books and these characters play similar roles even though they act differently. Just as Skeetah has an understanding that Esch hooks up with boys and is pregnant, Nathan's mother understands what his father is doing to him. While both choose to remain ignorant or pretend to be Skeetah does so out of protection while Nathan's mother is too afraid to get involved. Although she does give him warnings and tries to indirectly protect him by giving him food and calling his father back to their room she is not much of a protector. Skeetah ends up saving Esch's life and it is not sure where Nathan's mother will come into play later on. Also like "the pit" in Salvage the bones there is the woods in Dream Boy. Each conceals what really goes on and has its own set of rules that counter society's. It sometimes offers protection and other times leads to danger. The setting is crucial to the step of both novels and I'm assuming there will be more connections continuing throughout the novel.
Reaction to Dream Boy
Jim Grimsley's novel Dream Boy is an incredibly gripping story from its onset. I think that Grimsley, while a simple writer, has a way of making his easy sentences both beautiful and loaded. The way that subtext functions in the novel, both literally and figuratively (with the relationship between Roy and Nathan then with Grimsley's writing), has me hooked. The way in which Grimsley has constructed and described Nathan's world is captivating in a morbid way. As a reader, I feel like this book is the metaphorical car wreck that I am so curious about that I can't look away from, even though I know the subject matter it is dealing with is so, so gut wrenching and fills me with trepidation.
I myself read about six books a week leisurely, and another three academically, so it is sometimes difficult for a story to stay with me, but Dream Boy is haunting. I feel like the text, ridden with symbolism, is responsible for that. I'm often on the edge of my seat as I read, and I am really eager to see where this novel goes, thanks to the little scraps of information Grimsley has thrown my way. I think that Dream Boy functions in a realm where a lot of novels don't go, and it explores topics that are considered taboo to many. This really doesn't bother me. I don't think this book is any more graphic than a lot of popular novels or shows, so it's a funny concept to me that it might render some people uncomfortable. But maybe that is because it functions outside the realm of what has been constituted normative in a cigender, heterosexual, androcentric society.
This book explores what is beyond the boundaries of acceptable and borders on dangerous, and I love it. This is quite possibly one of my new favorite books. I'd even venture so far as to say, as an English major, it is one of the best books that I've had to read in my academic career. That is all, of course, determinate upon the ending. I usually only read books without subject matter that can trigger any sort of discomfiture, or that end happily - which certainly can't be said thus far about Dream Boy, because all signs point towards an unfortuitous end for not only Roy and Nathan's relationship, but most importantly Nathan himself.
I myself read about six books a week leisurely, and another three academically, so it is sometimes difficult for a story to stay with me, but Dream Boy is haunting. I feel like the text, ridden with symbolism, is responsible for that. I'm often on the edge of my seat as I read, and I am really eager to see where this novel goes, thanks to the little scraps of information Grimsley has thrown my way. I think that Dream Boy functions in a realm where a lot of novels don't go, and it explores topics that are considered taboo to many. This really doesn't bother me. I don't think this book is any more graphic than a lot of popular novels or shows, so it's a funny concept to me that it might render some people uncomfortable. But maybe that is because it functions outside the realm of what has been constituted normative in a cigender, heterosexual, androcentric society.
This book explores what is beyond the boundaries of acceptable and borders on dangerous, and I love it. This is quite possibly one of my new favorite books. I'd even venture so far as to say, as an English major, it is one of the best books that I've had to read in my academic career. That is all, of course, determinate upon the ending. I usually only read books without subject matter that can trigger any sort of discomfiture, or that end happily - which certainly can't be said thus far about Dream Boy, because all signs point towards an unfortuitous end for not only Roy and Nathan's relationship, but most importantly Nathan himself.
Fear No More
Dream Boy by Jim Grimsley truly reflects what the southern atmosphere holds against homosexuality. Nathan, especially, has an exceptionally hard time coping with his feeling towards Roy, knowing his father as an avid church-goer would not approve, considering his father already does not like Nathan going out with Roy for the evenings out into the woods. Nathan not only has to live up to what his father expects of him such as going to church on the evenings, but Nathan also feels obligated to live up to what Roy wants of him which may very well clash at some time in the story. Traditionally, the South does not accept homosexuals within the church. Can Nathan's fear towards Roy and his father be a mere consequence of a relationship that eventually the whole town will know about? Nathan is wrapped up in a position that he is slowly losing control of. Knowing that his father is always in the back of his mind conflicts with Nathan's judgment about his relationship with Roy. And what about the simple fact that Nathan is reminded of his father when he catches a certain look in Roy's eyes? Nathan is afraid of his father. Why? Nathan knows he is going against what his father and church have taught him is whole life about homosexuality, but there must be something far greater that is frightening Nathan about his father.
At some point though we do see where Nathan has greater control than Roy. One evening after a swim with Randy and Burke by the river, Roy drives Nathan down a dead end by Riggstown where they are isolated by any possible encounters. Intimacy grows between the two boys, causing Nathan to feel he has more control over Roy, guiding Roy's movements as they make love inside the car. But Nathan's control goes against him when Roy feels suspicious towards Nathan's natural sexual abilities. Could this be a reoccurring cycle where Roy initiates his dominance over Nathan, or, will Nathan naturally take control of being the aggressor? If so, Nathan's fear will no longer be a result of consequence, but what will if their relationship is discovered?
At some point though we do see where Nathan has greater control than Roy. One evening after a swim with Randy and Burke by the river, Roy drives Nathan down a dead end by Riggstown where they are isolated by any possible encounters. Intimacy grows between the two boys, causing Nathan to feel he has more control over Roy, guiding Roy's movements as they make love inside the car. But Nathan's control goes against him when Roy feels suspicious towards Nathan's natural sexual abilities. Could this be a reoccurring cycle where Roy initiates his dominance over Nathan, or, will Nathan naturally take control of being the aggressor? If so, Nathan's fear will no longer be a result of consequence, but what will if their relationship is discovered?
A Comparison
Dream Boy is a very significant piece of literature when it comes to relation towards the south simply because of the homosexual features within the novel and the stereotypical opinion that the south has towards homosexuality. Nathan and Roy are both very unique characters who both have very deep intimate feelings toward each other. Their sexual tension reminds me of the character in A Streetcar Named Desire named Blanche. Their similarities are expressed in the acts of love within darkness just like Blanche preferred. This could possibly be because of the rejection of their society amongst homosexuality. To this day, homosexuality is widely rejected across the south, therefore it makes it hard for gays to feel comfortable with their sexuality in public.
Roy can also be compared to Stanley in A Streetcar Named Desire because of his bipolar signs of his feelings toward Nathan. This is just like Stanley when he reacts to Stella aggressively because of her sister Blanche. Roy’s fear of being judged amongst his peers may also have a great deal to do with his unpredictable behavior towards Nathan. Nathan supports this by his tendency to act ‘normal’ around Roy, even when it is extremely clear that he has a strong feelings for Nathan. It can be predicted that the struggles between Roy and Nathan can possibly lead to the downfall of their relationship. Their dirty secret seems that it will eventually be revealed to their peers and family, and it will provide for an interesting new take on the novel.
Lovers in the Night
The story of Nathan and Roy is wrought with secrets and
lies. Their relationship shows the stigmas attached to being gay in a society
that rejects homosexuality. Interestingly, Roy-the popular, cool kid- is the
aggressor in the relationship. He has to keep up his façade of dating Evelyn,
while suppressing his feelings for Nathan. Nathan is the new kid on the block,
placing him in a vulnerable position amidst his high school peers. Adolescents
can be crueler than adults, especially when they are all just trying to be a
part of a group. Everything during adolescence is based on acceptance. Roy and
Nathan fear that they will be rejected for having feelings for the other. The
fear of rejection from peers results in Nathan and Roy hurting each other. Roy
treats Nathan inconsistently. One minute he’s affectionate and the next he is
downright cold. Roy’s inner struggle to accept himself and possibly criticism
from others is hurtful to Nathan. However, Nathan understands the secrecy of
the situation and acts discreetly around Roy.
The
only time Nathan and Roy are intimate is at night. It’s as if the boys feel
protected by the darkness, but they are afraid to be themselves in the light.
Roy and Nathan’s relationship reminds me of the Bright Eyes song, Lua:
“But me I'm not a gamble/ you can count on me to split/The
love I sell you in the evening/ by the morning won't exist.”
Obviously, Roy is saying this to Nathan. On top of all of
the hormones that have to be repressed during adolescence, Roy and Nathan have
to repress who they really are. This means lying to themselves and thus
everyone else. These lies may prove to be incredibly self-destructive for Roy
and Nathan.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



