Thursday, October 30, 2014

In the words of Bukowski, "People are not Good to Each Other"


I’m appalled by the atrocities that Gawker had to deal with at the hands of people:  peers at school, , those charged with  power at the school , strangers on the street, and even his own mom. People at the school are contemptible. They are outrightly vicious towards him and the school does nothing to stop this sort of thing but rather perpetuates it by punishing Gawker, adding insult to his injury. When he takes to writing and speaking out against it, the white students and faculty have the nerve to be angry at him as though they have any right at all to be.  A student actually feels entitled enough to say that it would be justified in killing Gawker for talking out against injustices he faces and a professor actually gives this kid a platform as though this is just a perfectly sane and justified thing to desire. It’s all so crazy.  The reputation of the school being evolved past racial rifts is kept up by the most dishonorable means because after all it’s not about making a true impact in the world and taking measures to address social issues; it’s about selling lies and wearing an empty smile, and saying that nothing is wrong because that’s the easier thing to do; challenging the issue would be too much. 
        
When Gawker says, “I think and feel a lot but mostly I feel I can’t do anything to make the boys feel like they’ve made us feel “ it’s a very low moment because there’s the sense that Gawker is overcome with such a dark, heavy feeling and that he can’t do anything to lessen this feeling. It wouldn’t matter if he killed them because he’d still feel the horrible way he did.

It’s curious to me that Gawker keeps telling himself “I don’t know what’s wrong with me” whenever he’s feeling anger and frustration due to being in a situation where he’s being tormented. These cruel things happen over and over and over again to him, and no one stands up for him, no one says this is wrong, no one acknowledges that he is being wronged, no one ever has, it seems, and so he questions his normal reactions and feelings. Later on, when he explains that his mom raised him to be like a robot, to be pleasing all the time, to walk on eggshells around white people, and basically remain inhibited at all times, I understand that this is a part of why he asks himself what is wrong with him.  This brings me to the mom. Surely, it is crazy that the mom had to raise him this way, raising him with such fear and overbearing self-awareness and weariness and lack of freedom  but it was how she had to love him, how she white-knuckled him to keep him safe, alive.  I cannot imagine being in her shoes.  Surely, freedom, and defending one’s freedom by whatever means is a very romantic idea, but when it comes down to a choice between your son’s freedom and his life which would you choose? It wasn’t a black and white, weighed out choice; it was a choice made subliminally, instinctively everyday to make sure that he would be safe.  It was never, “Am I going to sacrifice my son’s freedom to keep him safe?” It was, “I have to keep him safe”.  Then we see Gawker forcing her to look at the mental slavery she’s under and to see that they’re compromising themselves to fall in line where they can never really fall in line, or (as free individuals) should ever want to fall in line. This truth “kills” her. This scenario helps me to make sense of when he says, “Lots of times, we’ve taken turns killing ourselves slowly, before trying to bring each other back to life”, She’s been killing him and he’s been killing himself and her but the killing is a stimulus which provokes a reaction that breathes life into the deflating souls or at least slows the speed of some other impending, form of ‘death’.

“I wish I could get my Yoda on right now and surmise all this shit into a clean sociopolitical pull-quote that shows supreme knowledge and absolute emotional transformation, but I don’t want to lie.” Gawker’s experiences were real, they were horrible and should not be sweetened to better suit anyone’s palate. People are not good to each other. Gawker has many scars to show for it.

progress?

Kiese Laymon wrote a fascinating and powerful essay that is very eye opening. The writing style almost sounds poetic, but as well as a narrative story. His essay displays the obvious racism in this country. People many think that America has made great progress since the Civil Rights, but I think Laymon would disagree. One thing I found particularly troubling was the long list he makes regarding things his mother has warned him about.  I find it insane how many everyday situations must be reacted upon very carefully because one accident can change everything. Just now, writing that previous sentence, I was struggling to find the right word. Phrases like "one wrong move" or "one mistake" first came to mind, but with more thought I realized those were the wrong words. Such simple actions such as speeding, wearing certain clothes, being careful who one hangs out with. Those are not mistakes, those are not wrong moves. That is injustice. One's whole life should not change due to minor actions. I've known about the world Laymon writes about, I've never experienced it, but I've never been naive regarding that part of society. Reading this changes perspective, it's so much more powerful and real.

the insistence of memory

How to Slowly Kill Yourself and Others in America is, to me, a story that finds consolation without conclusion: Kiese Laymon earns identity through his writing but does not claim the higher implications of his essay- "This is not a woe-is-we essay" and "I wish I could get my Yoda on right now and surmise all this shit into a clean sociopolitical pull-quote that shows supreme knowledge and absolute emotional transformation, but I don't want to lie."

Instead Laymon's essay is a willful excavation of memory. He implies that our identity, as individuals and as communities, insists upon being remembered, especially those "complicated, muffled truths of our lives and deaths and the lives and deaths of folks all around us over and over again."

On a personal level there was very little I could find relatable. And I believe that is why I found this essay so fascinating. No matter ow man history classes I take, no matter how many times I read The Tempest or Huckleberry Finn and no matter how long I live in the south, I will always be me.

 I am an upper-middle class white-boy from the great state of Minnesota. Every portion of this country has a history of racial violence- blacks were hanged all of a mile from my souhern Minneapolis suburban utopia no more than sixty years ago. But the city I grew up in, the Minneapolis of today, the patchwork quilt of race and class with the highest employment rate and one of the lowest crime rates in the country, is an entirely different galaxy from the one Laymon describes in his essay.

I will never know what it means to be Black in America. I will never know what it means to be Kiese Laymon.

Speaking Truth

To this day, I am disturbed by the longing harmful actions of humans toward one another. As a Caucasian female, raised in a diverse community, I am saddened by how society still teaches young children to grow up with the notion that the color of our skin determines who we are. Gawker's story doesn't surprise me one bit. He makes an astounding point of how people are killing themselves before bringing others back to life. People of all races indirectly encourage each other to play the games of racism without even knowing it, prolonging the deadly effects of a racist society. America's racist issue is a tough topic to pick on as a young Caucasian female. But, what I can confidently say is, I am young, and I am aware of what society makes of its people. And I am aware of the corruption and false accusations made on people, especially living in New Orleans. I have witnessed cases like Gawker explains in his essay from his mere experiences of being a black male. The truth is awful. But I have hope as well. Our generation lacks the education to execute a hateful society of race. But as children, if children are taught to love, taught see each individual by heart, taught to be aware of the mistakes made, and are taught to seek for unity in diversity, then yes, I do believe as America, society can mend the heartbreak made by American history. I may sound a like an oblivious peacemaker, but what I am saying will help. Now of course, American history cannot be changed but as long as people in power and people of society favor one race over another, and encourage the topic of racism to be brought up after every crazy incident like the Travon shooting, then we live in this vicious cycle of hatred, possibly creating a civil war in the long run. There is hope. That is all I am saying.

On Anger, Ferguson and Why KA is Terrible

           This essay is the type of thing that often gets described as “powerful.”  I know because that’s the first word I thought of when I read the essay, and I knew immediately that it was a cliché.  I also read a few of the comments. There's nothing wrong or inaccurate about this description, but I think whenever these types of stories are shared, that's the go-to word, and I have to note that if I still intend to use it to describe this essay.
            The thing that struck me most after I read this essay was the narrator’s tone, his solemn but enlightened attitude, as though he had at least partially made peace with the life he lives and the world he lives in.  I feel like when it comes to Trayvon Martin and the like, there is a lot of pressure for us to be angry about everything.  If we don’t have a Ferguson situation every time something bad happens, we’re not doing our job.  We’re supposed to riot, fight, shout “fuck the police,” show our anger.  I was angry, do not get me wrong, but that’s not the only thing I feel about being black in America; it’s not even the main thing I feel.  I once heard the (possibly fake) tidbit that the human brain only naturally remains angry for about ninety seconds and that everything after that is us consciously choosing to remain angry.  I think of that every time I start to choose anger as a response to something, particularly racial tensions.  That’s what remains with me about this essay.  The author discusses all of his emotional responses to his life: depression, fear, hatred and yes, anger.  But he also goes deeper than that.  His essay isn’t about the reactions themselves, but the what actions they lead us to and what creates these reactions.
          
  The essay also tells us how people react when presented with inherent racism.  The author of this article was writing about racism and his writings were considered “disturbed.”  The Kappa Sigma and Kappa Alpha fraternities were not punished as a whole for having members in blackface during bid day.  Let me digress for a moment and say that racist costume parties are one thing—yes they’re insensitive, but themes are hard and everyone really wants to believe that their thing is the thing that’s at the line without crossing it.  Parties are like a subset of the essence of Greek life.  But bid day?  Bid day is the day when your organization welcomes new members and celebrates what your organization stands for and what it means to be a(n) (insert organization).  So yeah, having racist parties is bad, but wearing blackface on bid day is basically saying, “we stand for racism.”


But I digress.

United States of Hatred

I thought this article was very powerful, and did an excellent job of showing what it's like to be a person of color in America today. Though the civil rights movement did a lot towards the fight for equality, there still remains an overbearing presence of racism in America today, and though "all men were created equal," they certainly aren't treated that way. I think a lot of instances of racism are more prevalent in the South however still, as the article's author Kiese Laymon shows, sharing his experiences coming from Mississippi. What struck me most about Laymon's article was when he described the backlash he received from the articles he wrote for his college newspaper - even though the race articles weren't the ones that got him in trouble. Rather, his race became an issue as a writer, because he was bold enough to be controversial in his articles, and because he expressed his opinions. I was blown away that he received death threats, and someone even went so far as to slash his mother's car's tires. This really illustrates just how toxic hatred and racism are in driving people to horrific actions. A person who experiences privilege in America won't ever experience this, or be able to understand what it's like to be hated for no rational reason, but simply for the color of their skin. I never really felt like I could fully understand the race issue in America until I experienced it first hand. Reading about it from Laymon is shocking and horrific, but its so much more gutting when it is undergone, and I can't imagine experiencing it on a daily basis, being that fearful all the time. The worst instance of racism I've faced was in the rural South where I was told to stand in another line separate from my father at a store, who got to remain in the white line. My mother is Hispanic and Native American, whom I take after in appearance. This was a really shaking experience, and when I read about Laymon being pulled over by the belligerent white cop, that really reminded me of how in America, you can be singled out for your race. It's 2014 and in some places segregation is still something that occurs. While not legally enforced, it is still heavily implemented in certain areas of the country, showing how hate still infects peoples hearts, and spreads fear in others'. When Laymon talks about the behavior of the fraternities, it only shows that systematic racism is still accepted, which is horrific and disgusting. I think Laymon does a really amazing job of conveying not only fear but also anger in his article, which in a way almost bears another form of hatred in itself, which isn't without grounds. The point that Laymon makes is outstanding, that all of this is killing Americans on the inside, by eating away at their compassion and humanity.

Stereotypes Approved

It is a sad sight to see the racism that is prevalent today. Some individuals have a hard time getting over the past, especially in very traditional southern areas such as Mississippi. It also disappoints me that the peers of Gawker would even think that it is acceptable to treat an individual that way. My entire side of my mother’s family is from Mississippi, and it is sad to say that I have experienced this ongoing racism with my eyes. The differences between white folks and black folks in Mississippi are astronomical nonetheless the entire south. Gawker has always had to watch his back and his mother even teaches him this by explaining that he is never off of parole. She lists off a series of rules that he must follow to insure his safety as a black male in the south. Her words are quite powerful yet eerie, “...never ever forget I was on parole, which means no black hoodies in wrong neighborhoods, no jogging at night, hands in plain sight at all times in public, no intimate relationships with white women…” this is a violation of human dignity and our fundamental rights. Racism is a battle that has been fought ever since our country was founded. We would assume that a remedy would have taken place by now, but it is evident that no such remedy has occured. As a civilized society it is up to us to find out a solution to this severe and demoralizing problem.

Born into a unknown world of hatred

    I have no idea where to start, but what is stated in this article is showing the true colors of what society has become in today's time period.  I have come to conclusion about racist people amongst us.
There are a few different kids of racist people. The first kind of racist person is the norm that most have in their mind a white guy who is against everything an African American is doing. That is what most would agree on is the normally racist typically guy. Furthermore, a different in more in depth type of racist is an African American person who hates his own ethnicity. Meaning having hatred for those who share the same skin color, due to the fact of those black racist people feeling like the people they have hatred for is not living up to the expectation of a what an African should be. However, this form of racism may not be what is the norm of our society but this form of racism share a few of the same characteristics as of what everyone is use to because of both show negative bias towards a certain ethnicity. Lastly, as shown in the article I believe that racism drilled  into kids  minds within the household as shown how the kid was pulled over by a drunk cop and held him at gun point as well another cop came but what you have to pay attention and you will see the reason I said this is because lastly a another police officer came the same race as the first cop John Dree and he let the kids go with no tickets or jail time, in which this proves my point of racism is not in ever everyone it is taught with the household or family.

  As for the last have of the article, I believe that it is very horrible that now a days we have to walk around with protection and have to look over our shoulders because we feel unsafe in our own neighbors. Everyone scream about how the government doing this or that, how a cop shot a kid, but never have I seen a protest how a little girl got chopped unc by a babysitter or how a young innocent little girl gets raped and no one wants to believe her or even people killing one another for no reason just of the fact they see someone doing it and every they live around things its cool so more and more kids get drawn into that lifestyle. We don't know we are slowly killing ourselves. No one is stopping us from doing anything but us. We as a whole are becoming more and more blind to the fact that no one can make you live a life you don't want to live. God created each and every one of us different for a reason, and I believe that reason is because each individual have there own destiny in live. Either Break out those mental handcuffs and be who you want to be or keep living a life of regret


There is Nothing Wrong with You


Throughout the whole article, Laymon constantly questions himself  “What’s wrong with me?” This shows how society’s view of him as a “black boy” has infiltrated his psyche and made him second-guess himself. Laymon is clearly an introspective person and he looks inward for the roots of his issues instead of lashing out and blaming others. However, in this case especially, Laymon is not to blame. Laymon’s story illustrates the core issues of internalized racism. The stigma of being black in America has become internalized, causing him to question himself and his worth. This is where self-blame comes in. Society finds it easier to blame the victim rather than confront the underlying issues. While Laymon does not consider himself a victim, it is obvious that he has been persecuted because of the color of his skin. His words incited controversy on his campus likely because he was black. If a white student raised the issues Laymon wrote about, there would likely not have been such an uproar. Laymon’s essays made people feel uncomfortable. He spoke about real experiences that the white community of Millsaps wanted to deny. 
Again, it was easier to blame Laymon for causing trouble when the reality is that the trouble was already there—Laymon just chose to talk about it when no one else would.

Racism is Very Much Alive

This was a powerful piece of writing. The stories that Kiese Laymon tells can really hit home with people; especially if they are going through similar issues. When I was reading it, I felt a little disturbed by how he was being treated. I know that racism is still alive today, but to read about several racist events that happened to one person is frightening. I started to put myself in his shoes to try to see what he felt. I cannot even imagine the pain he felt: the need to strangle someone for being called a “nigger”, having your own mother pull a gun on you, having a kid rob you at gunpoint, and worst of all, pulling a gun on yourself. The most uncomfortable take away from Laymon’s experiences is that it is very recent. These kinds of things can still happen to people today, and not only in Mississippi, but almost anywhere. I’ve never had any experiences as extreme as Laymon’s, but by being an African American male, his stories slightly affected me. I am already aware of how young black males are viewed in society, but he made me realize that it is possible to overcome these kinds of events; even when death is knocking at your door. These things happen every day, whether it’s in Mississippi, Louisiana, Alabama, or any other state for that matter. Racism is a prevailing issue that has to be addressed. Society needs more stories such as this one so that people can learn more about the problems that we as a people are facing. 

Wednesday, October 29, 2014

The race to end racist actions

My first reaction to this story was when was this written it has to be a long time ago. But then I reflected on how many stories like this have been in the news in the last year or so. I thought of the Treyvon Martin discussion I went to last year. I thought of the reading of Jesmyn Ward's Men We Reaped. I thought of the vigil LUCAP board is planning for the recent murders of New Orleans youth. This issue is so prevalent in our society today. It is something that is difficult to talk about but for now I think discussion is the way to start to solve the problem.  Acknowledging that this stuff does take place everyday and in our community and addressing why it is wrong is the first step. Sometimes it feels like something distant and unreal, it doesn't touch our own lives. But there are teenagers still growing up with these problems. Gawker showed how many of these lives go by unnoticed or even looked at as in the wrong, as he was. He ask brought up a good point that it doesn't matter if they are physically killed. These problems are damaging the lives of these affected with mental issues and opportunities lost. It seems we get excited about these issues when something happens and is brought up in the media. But to solve these problems its going to be a long process and reminders of what we need to do as a society to better and rid o this issue.
     In the story of "Hunting Years" by Tom Franklin, a man recalls his past and the struggle of reaching masculinity among his peers. Tom Franklin comes from a lineage of hunters and sharpshooters who had a natural skill for hunting with firearms. Unlike his younger brother and his father, Gerald Franklin, Tom was different and was somewhat opposed to the nature of the sport. He could be paralleled to being the black sheep of his ancestry or the mutation gene in a genetic sequence.
     From this, the issue of his adolescence does not become one of masculinity, but one of continuing tradition. Because of his long family succession of huntsmen, Tom was obligated to follow the tradition in the sense that it was expected of him, a norm you could say. If you label his family as a society of its own, it was only natural that he succeeds in following the social norms and conforms to what is expected of him. But, just as any other radical change or deviation from comfortable surroundings, there was panic and a sense of hostility over the sudden change. His adolescence seemed more about a battle over conformity rather than a decision over masculinity. It was noted that his father was a well-known huntsman within a populous of huntsmen as a legendary killer of turkeys. It is only natural that his offspring follow suit in the same path. This expectation is what built up the intensity of being a Hunter. But just as the passion was growing, it was becoming heavier for Tom to bear and soon would come crashing down when his inability to succeed his father surfaced.
     The issue at hand was that this hunter-to-be was not living up to the anticipated title, and it was this that stirred confusion and trouble. Tom Franklin was the change in a believed set-pattern and his experience during his youth was the reaction to this change.

To Be Hunter Is to Be Man

Masculinity in Hunting Years is performed by literal pursuing and conquering. The goal is to identify prey and achieve mastery and power over it by killing it.  We get the impression that, a man, in order to be healthfully masculine, needs to hunt and be interested in toying with guns and knives.  If it is hunting season a man would better be enthused about clutching his gun against his chest and setting out to kill something. A boy, even, was expected to be taken with hunting. This is the best thing for the healthy male to enjoy doing with his time; to chase and to pursue, to have control over the life force of whatever animal is hunted, as though this is how to verify and prove his power and capability. If a male was interested in less grossly exertive activities, he could forget about being respected. To be a legendary man who commands respect is to be a skilled hunter, there is no more admirable way. A father’s aspiration for his son is that the son will be a master hunter. 

We see all the men in Hunting Years being so thrilled and taken with hunting as if the only worthy thing a man can be is a hunter and that to be more interested in anything that is not hunting, is to be a weak man, a pussy. Young Tom does not desire at all to partake in hunting activities; he’d rather play with his action figure dolls and reading books. He is made to feel, by the men around him (especially his father) that these interests are rather pitiful and invaluable to him as a male. To perform masculinity, a man has to set out pursuing something (something living is best) capture it, and conquer it in a way that there can be no doubt that the man is powerful. About killing his first deer, Tom said, “For the first time in my life, I wasn’t a pussy. I was a man who’d enjoyed his first taste of blood and wanted more.” The kill had made him a man. So we see that for the men in Hunting Years , hunting and drawing blood, is the ultimate performance of masculinity.

Hunting of a strong gender

   In "Hunting Years" by Tom Franklin, a man relives his childhood experiences as a boy. Furthermore, as a child he was pushed and battered by his family to hunt. In which hunting was a norm for his family and no other recreational sport mattered. Evidence of the loyalty the little boys family has towards hunting is when the narrator stated that if the boy doesn't want or like to kill things he will be consider weak and less of a man. This form of masculinity shows how kids cant dream from them selves and are forced into something they really don't to. Furthermore, kids cant be themselves because they are afraid of being socially judge as well as being judge by his or parents.

    However, "Hunting Years" in my opinion this novel is is kind of cruel do to the fact I never believed in forcing anyone to live a lifestyle that I live. In life a child is supposed to be able to dream be who ever he or she wants to be and the family is supposed to be the number one support through it all. Additionally, in today's time society has made a major impact of the way kids live their life. Kids become afraid to be who they want to be due to being afraid of being socially judge such as if a guy doesn't want to play sports he's called weak or less of a man. Additionally, female children has that same problem with gender inequality, meaning society believe a man should run things. A woman doesn't deserve the power to be president, a football coach, etc. This may sound crazy but I believe in everyone should be treated equal and as stated before a child should have the choice to be who he or she wants to be an don't judged by the masculine or non-masculine things of life in which the novel "Hunting Ideals" potrayed fairly well.

Tuesday, October 28, 2014

A Man As a Hunter

Hunting is a very respected sport, or lifestyle (I should say) in the south. Many who engage in hunting might even consider it tradition. From the time a boy shares his interests of becoming like his father, he are taught the lifestyle of hunting. Tom Franklin shares his experience to his readers how he evolved from a boy who once took interest in his G.I Joe dolls to the time he shot his first buck.
Masculinity plays a large part behind Tom's story. He blatantly shares with his reader that "a boy who didn't hunt was branded as a pussy." So, Tom adopted the devotion it would take to become just like his father, a man who had the most respect from known hunters in town. Tom's father hunted turkeys, waking up earlier than anyone else, before dawn, and staying out later than anyone else could even bare with the icy weather. Tom's father had patience for his prey, lighting up a cigarette if it meant waiting until it was time to shoot. He went to church, never cursed, and even became a  deacon. He didn't brag about his successful hunting career, but his family would praise his legendary act of hunting that got around.
Tom learns what masculinity is through his father's lifestyle, and the pressure of his younger brother, who began adopting hunting skills at an earlier age than Tom. Tom gained the realm of victory and manhood by the time he killed his first buck. "For the first time in my life, I wasn't a pussy."
The performance of gender in Tom's essay really captures the strong roles of a man in the south, and the expectations of what it means to be a hunter. A hunter is patient, dedicated, quiet, and a lover of his church and family, in Tom's case.

Masculine Ideals

            In “Hunting Years” by Tom Franklin, a man recalls his experiences as a boy being pressured to hunt. In the story, masculine identity is directly linked to hunting. The narrator states that if he does not hunt and kill things, he is considered a “pussy.” This shows how societal ideas of gender can hurt men as they often do women, and why feminism (gender equality) is beneficial to both men and women. Men often feel societal pressure to be “masculine” meaning tough, unemotional—often bordering on cruel—and strong. A lot of this pressure comes from the societal patriarchy, images of men in television, movies and advertisements, but a lot it comes from within households. Another character who experiences this pressure would be Andy in the movie The Breakfast Club. Andy is said to experience a direct pressure from his father to be not only masculine, but also cruel to weak people. The pressure in this story is much more subtle; the main character experiences pressure from the ideas of his father coming from other male family members, but his father does not put pressure on him directly. He is haunted by the idea of his father in his youth as a strong hunter.

Not interested

"Hunting Years" was good the first few pages, but I did not like the rest. I hate hunting. I hate everything about hunting. Everything. I hate the color orange. I hate the color green. I think camo is disgusting. I have no interest in guns. I hate that killing animals is a sport. This piece was very descriptive and filled with imagery. The vivid descriptions were fine in the beginning and very disturbing for the rest. I don't want to read about how the animal bleeds and how he got blood on him and how he stabbed a deer 12 times. I hate how descriptive it was. With that being said, I think this article is a great representation of society. The guy doesn't want to hunt! But he forces himself to just so he's accepted and loved by his family. His mom was cool about his doll collection and his dad pretended to be, but it was clear he was not happy. He chose to be someone else so he wouldn't disappoint his family and be taunted by his peers. This is all because the boy wasn't interested in hunting. Although women struggle in society, men do as well. There is a lot more pressure for men to act a very specific way, and if one doesn't, he's not accepted.

The Lost Tradition

Tom Franklin comes right off the bat with a theme of masculinity in “Hunting Years.” The evidence of stereotypical masculinity is experienced throughout his writing. It reminds me of the quaint town that I grew up; where everyone hunted, everyone fished, and everyone knew each other. The stereotype of these masculine features proves to be different than any other part of the country. People fought very hard to fit in, “a boy who didn’t hunt was branded as a pussy.” is just one explanation. In a small southern community such as the wooded counties between the Alabama and Tombigee Rivers, the stereotype for masculinity is that of which you can find all across the south. People are more conservative, therefore the tradition is extremely evident.
Franklin continues to emphasize the performance of genders. The performance of males in the south differs greatly than those from up north. The scene when Franklin encounters the hunting club member on the railroad track furnishes a good example of what the men are like in this area. The members of the club explain the change that is ongoing in the south. It is not the same as it used to be and the land is seen as a recreational asset, but it really is the livelihoods of the ancestors that you used to inhabit it. The tradition is disappearing and it will continue to do so.

the performance of masculinity

The main performance of masculinity in Franklin's story is, obviously, hunting. Franklin bases this action as a right of passage into manhood handed down by his father and prescribed by the small backwoods town in Alabama he calls home. This, of course, brings about an interesting question: why hunting?

The first answer is that, traditionally, and not just within the small towns in the deep south, hunting is a man's job: the men hunt and provide food while the women stay in the house and bear children. This notion was ingrained in Franklin through familial and societal tradition: his father was "a legendary killer of turkeys" from a community of "the most seasoned woodsmen." This expectation for Franklin to perform is further manifested through the inheritance of his grandfathers shotgun, a single material object that insists adherence to tradition- "a rare Foxboro crafted of blued Sterlingworth steel."

Moreover, any attempt to reject or avoid this performance of manhood, which has been engrained by society, is, as Franklin so elegantly puts it, to be branded a "pussy." With this in consideration, Franklin seems to suggest that achieving masculinity not only equates to violence but the suppression of what society has perceived to be female characteristics- the inherently weaker sex.

But what I found to be most interesting in Franklin's story is that masculinity is only what certain people -whether that be family or society or culture or whatever- claim it to be. The best example of this can be found in the juxtaposition between the "fancy-rifled lawyer in face paint" that Franklin encounters on the railroad tracks and the Wiggins brothers from his childhood.

The latter of these are a prime example of the kind of masculinity Franklin had been expected to perform: "they were stringy, sun-yellowed boys who smelled like sweat and fish and never wore shirts or shoes in summer" (p8). Franklin, in fact, envied these boys for "the ease with which the accepted there lives, the way they spit between their teeth, flicked a rod, fired a rifle" (p9).

The man Franklin encounters on the train tracks, then, is not simply some lawyer failing to emulate masculinity: he is simply another brand in the market of masculinity's varying definition- granted a far less superior performance according to Franklin.



Gender: A Social Construction

Gender is put onto us, we are not born with it. We learn from the media, our friends, and our family the social expectations of how to act depending on what sex we are. We see this happen since the beginning of Tom Franklin's introduction when he talks about never wanting to kill anything, but being forced into hunting because he didn't want to be a "pussy." Hunting is their social expectation; it lets people know if you are actually a man, or if you're willing to be a real man. Franklin goes on to tell the reader how he preferred to play with G.I. Joe's and to please his father, and not seem like a weak boy he bought a knife instead of an outfit for he doll. This is another example of a social expectation on gender, and doing what you must to please others. Though his father said he was OK with the idea of him playing with dolls didn't change Franklin continuing to try and fit into the construction of his gender. And their excitement and proudness felt better than anything else to him. 

Of course what he must do to prove he is a man is different than other places. But we must not forget that his happens everywhere, every community, and family put expectations on boys on how to act and how to prove who they are. Or who they are suppose to be. 

Expectations of Gender

In the essay "Hunting Years," Tom Franklin goes to great length in the beginning of his writings to establish his origins. He writes about how he is from the South, Alabama to be exact, and that where he is from certain expectations are meant to be lived up to. He even emphasizes how he went to Arkansas and that doesn't truly constitute as the south. Franklin claims that in order to be a man in the South one needs to hunt animals. Hunting is associated with being a man in Franklin's south and anything less than that makes one less of a man. Franklin says that because he was 16 years old and still had yet to kill an animal he was a "pussy." Franklin doesn't even enjoy killing animals, yet he goes completely out of his way to go through the motions. He wakes up earlier than anyone else and sits in the icy cold weather to do something he doesn't even really want to do. He does it only so that he wont be perceived as a pussy to his family. To his family the proper thing for a man to do, is kill and anything less than that is unacceptable. In order to be a man in the south according to Franklin, he must go out of his way to do something that is uncomfortable to him. As a man I don't agree with this ideal, as to me being a man is standing up for ones own opinion even in the face of adversity. It's interesting that in this essay its the opposite, one must obediently sit down and say yes to what they are told to do in order to be a man. His justification being that they are from the south does not really hold water, and it seems like the standard has been set by his family more than the area he is from. It seems to be a generation thing that is passed down from one to the next. They claim it is where they are from when it is less the area they are from and more the environment of their family.

Killing A Boy's "Hart"

Mine (Colorado, 2012)
In Tom Franklin's story "Hunting Years" from his collection Poachers, masculinity is rooted in the practice of hunting. Growing up in lower Alabama, the narrator explains that boys were expected to participate in practices like hunting and fishing, and be enthusiastically interested in them, because they were normative masculine activities. Even though he didn't like it, the narrator would hunt, and began to show falsified enthusiasm for the sport. He says, "I never wanted to kill things, but I wasn't bold enough to say so," which eventually led him towards hiding his aversion by becoming "the most zealous hunter of all," because "a boy who didn't hunt was branded a pussy," (3). He explains that he "did the expected" (3), which came out of expectations born from gender roles. Growing up, he would feel guilty and foolish (2) when he made mistakes in regards to hunting and, in effect, masculinity. At one point, his gender identity is so heavily tied to hunting as masculinity that he felt ashamed for having other interests, even though they could be considered within the spectrum of masculinity, but for some reason inside his society do not - apparently a boy enjoying action figures is not the right kind of "rugged". Rather, his interest in his G.I. Joe and being able to buy it a new outfit, which would fuel his imagination, is considered too close to a feminine interest in dolls. Especially when his mother defends his desire to be imaginative to his father, the narrator feels ashamed, because he feels, on a subconscious level, that to value his G.I. Joe over a hunting knife is to be too closely aligned with feminine interests, which, with his upbringing, is wrong for a boy.
This story is interesting because it illustrates how strict gender roles can be and the confining, and really even constricting a presence they can be without being overt. It is considered monstrous in a way to o against what has been determined as normative in terms of respective gender roles and concerns.

Rigid and Strong

In society, a man is supposed to be tough, strong, an emotionally stable. In Tom Franklin's story, "Hunting Years", his portrayal of being a man does not stray too far from society's definition of a man. In the story, the protagonist grows up in a family where being a hunter means that you were a man. His brother, Jeff, and his father were both exceptional hunters, while he enjoyed playing with G.I. Joe action figures. Even though his father says that he is "...real proud..." of him, you can sense the sarcasm in his tone (Franklin 8). Also, the father tries to nudge him toward buying the hunting knife instead of things for his action figures. The reader can see that the father is happy that his son chooses the knife because he puts down ten extra dollars to help pay for it. The father relates to society's ideal man because of how tough he is, and also how he wants his son to be. Franklin also displays gender roles in his story. The parents' attitudes toward their son are that the father wants him to be tough and strong whereas the mother does not mind his playful and imaginative side. Franklin's interpretation of gender is similar to the common stereotypes of a man's a woman's attitudes toward their children.

Monday, October 27, 2014

Gender: A Social Construction

Gender isn't something we're born with it is a social construction and that is a major point Tom Franklin's story makes. From the start he isn't interested in hunting,"For some reason, I never wanted to kill things, but I wasn't bold enough to say so." This is an example of how gender is reinforced by family and friends. When he fits to the idea of how a boy and man should act he is praised and when he goes against it he is punished. Gender is not something children are born into, this is shown by Franklin's preferring dolls over hunting, "It was this kind of gift that let me know my father wanted me to hunt, though he never pressed, and let me know he was bothered by the fact that, until I was fifteen years old, I played with dolls." He is pressured to act a certain way, to live up to a standard. He feared being seen as "a pussy" and had to give up who he really was and hide his interests so he wouldn't be reprimanded. Although he says his father didn't press his ideals on him, he only praises him when he does meet the expectations of his father and otherwise he is harsh. It is very much similar to peer pressure but the pressure of not only his community but society. His situation is specific to where he grew up but there are gender expectations everywhere. His proudest moment is when he finally meets this standard and kills his first deer, he can finally be accepted into the community: "That was when everyone gathered around me, my uncles and Jeff clapping my back, Mom and my aunts hugging me, trying not to get blood on their blouses." It doesn't seem like anyone else that he looks up to really goes against performing this idea of gender so he sees it as being wrong. He isn't acting this way to fulfill what would really make him happy but everyone else. In the end he even has to continually get praise and do more it is never enough for him, he needs continual acceptance.

Dolls vs. Hunting

After reading Franklin's "Hunting Years", it was easy to see why there are so many issues with people being comfortable with their sexuality and gender identity. In his essay, masculinity is hunting. Having the strength, and stomach, and skills to hunt, is manly. His father, even as a deacon who doesn't hunt himself, tries to instill this on him. His father attempts to show him the "right" direction by recommending he buy a knife with his money, instead of another outfit for his GI Joe doll. At his school all the boys hunt, and if you don't you're labeled as inferior to those who do. It is a way to demonstrate your manhood and show that killing a living creature doesn't make you sick.

The performance of gender in Franklin's essay is done stereotypically. If you're a boy, you hunt, and if you're a girl, you play with dolls. His father seems to be worried about him because he enjoys playing with a doll more than killing animals. His mother is doing the "typical" motherly thing by telling his father to be more sympathetic.


Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Street Car Named Desire Comparisons between book and film

 After finalizing my readings of the book Street Car Named Desire  immediately after began to watch the film I notice many difference between the two. Furthermore, what i notice different between the two is that, in the book the characters are  being portrayed totally differently than from the film. Meaning in the book as I glanced through each sense as a reading I had the assumption that woman played a more dominate role than the men in the book than in the film due to how the author used particular words to describe each character giving the woman in the book more of dominant meaning than of the men. However, The author tried to make up for the lack of dominance from the male prospective by added sense will Stanley as well as the male who lives up theirs hits their wife supposedly letting them know they are in charge. In which, in the film the male dominance was a major factor moreover the women's role in the film. The male characters of the film played a even more aggressive role than the woman due to how the voices of the male characters or more aggressive and demanding than how soft and calm the woman's voice were. When reading a book the reader tries to assume what each character would sound like and only assume what is giving to them by the narrator. Whereas, in a film the person watching is actually hearing and experiencing what is going on and don't have to imagine in their minds on how each individual may look and sound like. Nevertheless, both film and the book share similar comparisons by which I can see how Mitch acts and feels about his mother and the scene from the poker night when Stanley yells Mitch's name and Mitch yells back book the book and the film showed the aggressive amongst both characters.

Cinematic Streetcar

Having read the play, watching the movie adaptation of Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire was certainly something else. Personally, I prefer reading a book or play because it allows me the freedom to cast my own characters, and picture the way I want events to play out. That's not to say I didn't like the movie, but maybe it differed from how I saw things in my mind. However, it was nice to be able to see events in action, and the ways in which characters behaved and interacted. And a lot of that has to do with the actors portraying them. I think being able to see the acting made the writing (of the play) a little more vibrant in my mind. What I did miss while watching was Williams' writing style - I like the way it flows and I find it really eloquent so for me, when it came to the movie, I really missed stage directions and scene descriptions. I even find that in his writing, Williams has a way of interjecting small, subtle nuances of character that could have perhaps been missed by the actor portraying them when they read the script and for me, when reading, those little hints stood out as very important for character development. I'm going to be honest and say that a black and white movie was hard to watch, too (even though one of my favorite movies is without color as well). But maybe that is because I was less invested in watching this depiction as I am in the one I created in my mind. I'll always be one of those people who holds to the mentality that the book - or in this case the play - is always better than the movie.

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Music and Place.

The first difference is the inclusion of the bowling which is only referenced to in the play. There is also the addition of other scenes, although brief and possibly insignificant, like the shot of Stanley coming home from work the morning after he assaults Stella. What is accomplished in these inclusion is somewhat difficult to determine, but it is possible that some degree of significance can be attained with the consideration of the one environment that is portrayed with consistency in both the play and the film: the Kowalski's apartment.

The apartment is the center of action in both mediums. In the play the a sense of closeness is accomplished through stage direction: different characters are constantly moving in and out of a single scene which, in turn, communicates a sense of confusion and stasis. Whereas in the movie, the director, Elia Kazan, created this claustrophobic atmosphere by moving the walls of the apartment closer with each scene.

It would seem, then, that the inclusion of additional scenes outside the apartment would work against this atmosphere. But these scenes in fact lend themselves to a state of stasis through musical accompaniment. Tennessee Williams described this process in the first scene of the play: "A corresponding air is evoked by the music of Negro entertainers at a barroom around the corner. In this part of New Orleans you are practically always just around the corner, or a few doors down the street, from a tinny piano being played with the infatuated fluency of brown fingers. This "Blue Piano" expresses the spirit of the life which goes on here."

The music freezes the characters, and perhaps the city of New Orleans, by the circumstance of their socioeconomic apartments, in the distillery of the "Blue Piano."  


Imagine "A Steetcar Named Desire"

There are several differences between reading the play A Streetcar Named Desire and  watching the film. One powerful difference can be made as a mean of the imagination. Reading dialogue allows one to put his or her own interpretations in play with the story line. The imagination allows for all sorts of perspectives to be seen about the characters and plot of the story as opposed to watching the film. The film only allows one solid interpretation to be portrayed for viewers watching A Streetcar Named Desire. Films have a tendency to alter or tweak stories in a way that makes the film either more entertaining or fitting for the audience, such as the scene when Blanche screams at Mitch to go away after he tells her she would not be worthy enough to be brought home to his mother. In the book, Blanche reacts to Mitch's rejection by letting out a frightening yell, "fire!" In the film, Blanche just screams hysterically, loud enough where the whole neighborhood can hear her.
As much as the film limits one's imagination to create the story to one's understanding, the film also may help clear up any misinterpretations or blurriness about the plot and characters. Stanley, Stella's husband, we know is a rough, drunk, boisterous man who does not compromise himself for anybody. The film displays an extra emphasis on how strong Stanley's character really is: crashing things, throwing plates, yelling almost every time he speaks. While reading the play, I didn't imagine Stanley to pull such a strong mannerism in just about every scene especially when Stanley and Blanche have a dramatic outbreak while Stella is in the hospital. Stanley nearly goes mad to the point where he looks like he is about to hit Blanche across the face, which he eventually does.
Reading the play and watching the film both go hand-in-hand to compare and contrast the various perspectives about the story.

Streetcar Named Desire Book and Movie

It is always so interesting to watch a movie based on a book you've just read because you picture certain characters, and how they act and how they look. I think because Streetcar Named Desire is a play, it was always difficult to really imagine Blanche and how she really carried herself and how her mannerisms are. Vivien Leigh portrayed Blanche in such a perfect way, it makes me want to re-read the book. She brings out the traditional side Blanche wants to be so badly, but also shows how crazy Blanche really is. Marlon Brando is as genius as any of us would suspect, though I didn't picture Stanley as such a pretty boy like Brando is, he does get the role of Stanley down perfectly. The flirting was sometimes hard to catch throughout the play, but Marlon Brando really shows it with the looks he gives, and the ways he sometimes looks at Blanche. When I first pictured Stella I did not imagine Kim Hunter. I imagined Stella as a bit coyer, and more scared of Stanley than she seemed to be in the movie. 

In the movie you definitely see how much attention Blanche wants and needs from outside people, especially men. Whether it is people telling her she is pretty, or just noticing that she is there, she always makes sure she is noticed. Imaging this was a little difficult for me while reading the play, but the movie really made it clear to understand. I really enjoyed being able to understand the characters even better, and feeling like they are a little more real. 

Streetcar Named Desire Book and Movie Comparison

After reading a book and then watching the movie right after the book, one can notice several differences between the two. Between the book and the movie of A Streetcar Named Desire , there are numerous differences. One thing that the movie portrays well that the book does not is the actual acting of the characters. The movie shows the emotions and feelings that the characters show whereas reading the book, the audience has to interpret the feelings of the characters themselves. The same thing goes with the setting. Readers picture each scene with only a description given by the author. But by watching the movie, the audience can visualize the scene in its entirety. However, in the movie, some scenes were either altered slightly, greatly, or additional dialogue was added. For example, when Blanche was arguing with Mitch, the book's version had her yelling out "Fire" while in the movie, she simply yelled very loudly. Also, during the same scene in the movie, there was extended dialogue after Mitch ran off. Although the book and movie ran parallel to each other, each of them can give their audiences different views about how the overall story is told.

Script v. Movie- A comparison for A Streetcar Named Desire

There is always a comparison towards a piece of literature with a movie that portrays the writing visually. It is almost impossible to nail all of the parts of the literature accurately because every individual has a different contraption towards the story that is being portrayed. As I watched the movie, I noticed some significant differences contrasting towards the literature. For example, the relationship between Stanley and Blanche was portrayed to be more intimate than the book explained under my interpretation. Blanche was introduced into a failing relationship as soon as she showed up unannounced at Stella’s house on Elysian Fields. The book leaves many open ends on the interpretation on the characters while the movie makes it clear and evident. The author, Tennessee Williams took a lot of effort to explain the message of the play as the way he saw it. In contrast, the movie does not portray this effort very well. The major difference that I saw between the two was the actual setting. In the movie, you can actually see the image and visual of what goes on at the bowling alley when Stanley would leave. To contrast this, the book leaves you guessing. This could be simply because it is more difficult to provide accurate visuals of the different locations on stage rather than being on camera. Another difference in the movie is the scene with the young boy and Blanche. It is portrayed in the script that the young boy is rather timid towards Blanche as she kept trying to keep him around. In the movie, the young boy has an extremely hard time keeping his eyes off of her. To conclude, this explains my statement about how Tennessee Williams wanted to explain the message and characters exactly as he wanted to. The movie fails to achieve exactly that, but the movie is not that of great difference to those who would want to simply watch the movie over reading the script.

Streetcar movie vs book

The movie and book have many similarities Movie Blanche is very dramatic and almost as hard to understand as book Blanche. She is always irrational and begging for attention. I did not expect the character who plays Stella, I'm not really sure what I expected, but actress Kim Hunter was not what I expected. The movie really shows what a character Blanche. Towards the end you can see how hysterical and pathological she is. It's much easier to follow the storyline when people are performing it it. Blanche definitely seems to have some sort of mental instability and it's clear in the end that everyone when she gets taken that everyone around her realizes it. I liked the movie and book in different ways. I enjoyed the book because I could interpret in my own way and create my own character personalities.  I liked watching the movie because it was less ambiguous and more interesting at some parts.

Steetcar: The Movie


            There is something to be said about watching a movie based on a written play/book. With Streetcar, the movie really served to bring all of the characters to life in a way that the written work didn’t completely convey. The movie gave faces to all the characters that we had only read about. In the movie, a few things came across that didn’t while I was reading. Blanche and Stanley’s relationship was a lot flirtier than I initially picked up on in the written play. While it was obvious that there was a little bit of flirting, the movie really showed the complicated dynamic between Blanche and Stanley. When watching the movie, I felt that Blanche was a much more likeable person compared to in the book, even though the lines were completely the same. The movie also shed light on the nuances of Stella and Stanley’s relationship. While Stella is portrayed as the strong, stable and straightforward sister, her interactions with Stanley show her weaknesses. Stella is more socially acceptable because she’s a simple housewife, taking care of her husband and fulfilling wifely duties. Blanche, however, being single and promiscuous, is stigmatized by society. The movie really shows that Blanche may not be the attention-seeking, drama queen that she is treated as. On the contrary, she may incite resentment in Stanley because Blanche acts independently without taking orders from any man. When Blanche enters Stanley and Stella’s lives, she becomes the observer. Through Blanche, the audience learns that Stella and Stanley’s relationship is ultimately dysfunctional as they fight and make up at the drop of a hat. The movie really shows how Blanche became the scapegoat for everything that went wrong between Stella and Stanley, even though the two likely had problems long before Blanche ever showed up.

Sunday, October 5, 2014

Blanche and Stanley

I think the source of Blanche's animosity derives from her early lifestyle compared to her current lifestyle. She is used to a wealthy lifestyle and everything coming easy to her. She and her sister, Stella, used to live in a comfortable plantation house, but now, they have lost the plantation house and are barely able to support themselves. Blanche is having a hard time adjusting to living off the land while Stella on the other hand is content with living in a small apartment with a Polish immigrant as her husband. The hostility that Blanche has towards Stella comes from Stella's ability to be able to live comfortably in conditions that she did not grow up in; yet, Blanche is critical towards Stella for this reason.
Stanley, on the other hand, has a male-dominant personality. He thinks that because he is a man, he is entitled to everything his wife has, and he is able to establish dominance over her. He also does not return any of the affection that Stella shows to him because his male mindset makes him see Stella as only a woman; not the woman that he swore his "love" to.

Stella vs. Blanche

The animosity between Blanche and Stella is very evident throughout the play. The pair are sisters, who grew up in an upper-class childhood, on a plantation called Belle Reave.  Now, Stella lives in New Orleans, where people don't mind getting a little dirty, and Blanche comes to live her her after losing their plantation. The two main sources of animosity between the pair are Stella's living conditions, and Stanley. Stella, although Blanche's little sister, has always felt like the eldest - and Blanche isn't fast at clarifying. Blanche is a high maintenance, dependent, dramatic, and constantly needs her ego patted. Stella is more docile, she willingly jumps when Blanche tells her to, and constantly reassures her of her beauty and grace - however, when she begins to fire at her burly husband, Stanley, Stella begins to loose her tolerance.

Blanche does not approve whatsoever of Stanley, although she uses every opportunity she can at the beginning to flirt with him. She thinks he is a brute, and she not only can't stand to live with them, but also doesn't hide the fact that she doesn't think Stella should be with him. However, Stella is head over heels for him, and looks past his roughness with her, especially when he drinks.

Blanche also constantly hounds on Stella for her living conditions. She very obviously does not like New Orleans and its different, rambunctious atmosphere. She is still bitter about Stella leaving Belle Reave. However, Stella clearly loves where she's at, and who she is surrounded by. Tension fills the air whenever Blanche suggests the two leave and go somewhere different.

Blanche is a Wrench

                  There are numerous sources for Stanley’s animosity towards Blanche. First, Stanley is upset by Blanche’s surprise arrival. Further, Blanche’s ‘badittude’ really gets under Stanley’s skin. Stanley is a manly man and likely used to being in control of a situation. When Blanche shows up, unannounced, there is nothing that Stanley can do about it. Blanche has a “holier than thou” attitude, possibly stemming from the lavish lifestyle she is used to leading. Her attitude does not mesh well with Stanley’s blue-collar way of life. In addition, Blanche is a beggar in this scenario and she is trying to be a chooser. She constantly insults the way that Stella and Stanley live in such a small space. It seems that there is a large conflict in values between Stanley and Blanche.  Blanche believes that luxury is a necessity, while Stanley believes that luxury is superfluous. The dynamic between Stella and Blanche is interesting, as well. Stella seems to have values more aligned with her husband than with her sister. Stanley is probably annoyed that Stella defends Blanche instead of taking his side out right. Therefore, Stella’s relationship with her sister causes tension in Stella and Stanley’s marriage. Stanley continually blames Blanche for her current circumstances, making Stanley seem pretty insensitive. However, Blanche doesn’t make it easy to feel compassion for her. Clearly, Blanche is a monkey wrench in Stella and Stanley’s marriage.            

Friday, October 3, 2014

The Mystery Of The "Blache"

Blanche brings in a form of kind of being the antagonist character in this play. Blanche shows how she is opposed to all that Stanley tries to help her with from the beginning of the play. Furthermore, even though Blanche has no where to stay she the truth about her starts to come to like about her having an nonchalant attitude things and don't really care about anyone's feelings when she has an attitude and talk about the way they live and where they live. This causes conflict between Blanche and Stanley because first she shows up unannounced then she starts  criticizing Stanley living conditions as if he is a peasant to him. This result in Stanley beginning to wonder " Blanche talks as if she has all the money in the world" In which she was left with her family owned plantation" that anyone has yet to see. In addition, Stanley thoughts to think to himself how does Blanche gets money if she doesn't work. Now I'm not trying to be judgement here but my first thought when I first read this actually part of the play my first assume was that due to How beautiful she was and she said that she now how to basically seduce men, I figure she used that to here advantage and charge to be with here. This may haven't been the case but this was a first thought that formed in my mind. Lastly, Blanche is a cocky person one who I believe lives her life of  make belief stories, which Stanley is an very opinionated person as well so I am very curious on how this dual between the Mysterious Blanche and the self confident out spoken Stanley.

Primitive

In Tennessee Williams, a streetcar named desire, there are several things about Stanley that don’t quite sit well with Blanche. Firstly, he’s far from warm and hospitable. When Blanche arrives, he makes it a rather unceremonious occasion and makes sly innuendos at her. He immediately gives the impression that she’s an unwelcome burden to be tolerated rather than a welcomed guest. The following day, he has the nerve to search through Blanche’s trunk of personal items. As if that’s not rude enough, he accuses her of swindling her sister and cheating her of money that he believes he has a right in as well. It is not surprising that such a gruff, imperious attitude would put Blanche off.


We get the sense of Blanche being raised in a very lady-like manner in a town with the airs of ‘proper people’ and where the men were gentle-manly or at least tried to give the impression that they were. Now Stanley is the total opposite of what a gentle-man is. He doesn't concern himself with tactful, flowery speech, tender and gentle actions, or proper, neat, clean clothes. He speaks to his wife, Stella, rather roughly and matter-of-factly. He is very dictatorial and boisterous. In fact, Blanche sees him as a primitive beast when in a drunken rage he hit his pregnant wife. The following day Blanche goes on a rant about everything that is wrong with Stanley: he’s sub-human; an animal, not at all artistically or intellectually cultured, he lacks tenderness, and most alarmingly, he behaves like an uncivilized thing that may choose to strike at any moment.

Men Are Naturally The Worst

Just as a disclaimer, I've previously red A Streetcar Named Desire, I know exactly how the play ends so I'm entirely biased towards the relationship between Stanley and Blanche. That being said, Blanche has an unnecessary attitude from the get go. She's pretentious, she's a liar, and she's constantly wrapped up in her own world and feelings. And Stanley has all the reason to question her unannounced appearance. Stanley, a Polish immigrant, is far below the social status that Blanche, a posh Southern belle, is custom to. But of course, Stanley starts off the meeting with Blanche asking a modest, Southern woman about her marriage while changing in front of her. Immediately, that offends Blanche. Immediately, they start off on a bad note. Further more, Stanley only cares about Blanche's story because he thinks that he is being cheating out of Stella's inheritance, which isn't his to have in the first place. And then Stanley, starting in the second act, is really proving to be more of the driving force of the aggression between him and Blanche. All of the animosity between the two really stems from the fact that Stanley is a selfish and insane man who can't stand the posh life his wife's sister once led and who doesn't understand how to treat a proper Southern woman.

Thursday, October 2, 2014

Blanche

Blanche has got some attitude! We can tell from the very beginning that she is not going to be easy to deal with. The problem with her and Stanley clearly starts with her showing up without him knowing, and her attitude on the way they live and where they live. He is skeptical of her from the beginning, not sure where she gets her money, or if she is telling the truth about what happened to the family's plantation. He also always has something to say to her, like when Stella and Blanche show up at the poker game and Stanley is quick to tell her that he is not ready to leave. I can see Blanche becoming a problem because it is only the beginning of the book and she is already not getting along with people, and rubbing people the wrong way. She is also obviously the most beautiful, and I wonder if that will create problems because of her flirtation with Stanley. They do not particularly get along, and yet they flirt so it will be interesting how that plays out.

Blanche

Blanche shows up unannounced to visit her sister. The way she acts shows she has a sense of superiority. She is uncomfortable with Stella's living condition and think it's small. I think Blanche is very dramatic and opinionated. Her and Stanley seem to butt-heads frequently, he seems uninterested in dealing with her. He finds her lavishness unnecessary and wants to know where she gets money from and what happened to the family's plantation. Stanley is aggressive and Blanche doesn't really understand his and Stella's relationship. Blanche also has this nonchalant attitude about things. One example of that was when she brought up the plantation. She mentions things and then brushes them off and Stanley doesn't put up with that. He threw her clothes around and basically interrogated her about the plantation that she clearly knew nothing about. Right now in the book, Blanche seems kind of like an airhead. It's interesting to see the difference between the two sisters. More contrasting is Stanley and Blanche who are both strong personalities with a lot to say. In the end, Blanche is an uninvited guest, who comes off as ungrateful and slightly judgmental and isn't afraid to state her opinion. She definitely clashes with the other characters.

Drawing a Blanche

The sources of animosity first arise between Blanche and Stanley based upon the fact that she comes to live with Stanley and Stella. The problem with Blanche is her attitude - she puts on airs of superiority and criticizes the size and condition of Stanley and Stella's home, which is a hit to Stanley's masculine pride, making a dig on his ability to provide for his wife. Blanche has a rather loud mouth for somebody who is living under the roof of and off the charity of other people, having no place else to go herself. She is lavish and takes up a lot of space, encroaching on the life of the young married couple. Not only that, but Blanche begins to involve herself in her sister Stella's relationship with her husband Stanley. This makes Blanche a threat to Stanley, because she is in a place to undermine his relationship with his wife. She tries to convince Stella that she can escape Stanley's abusive ways, but Stella remains passive when it comes to her husband's violence. Stanley overhears Blanche's hatred for him, and gets one over on her by being secretive about it, and then deceptively jovial when coming upon the tail end of their discussion, after which Stella chooses him over her sister. This is seen through the stage direction, "Stella has embraced him with both arms, fiercely, and full in the view of Blanche. He laughs and clasps her head to him. Over her head he grins through the curtains at Blanche.]" (Williams 84). So not only do Blanche and Stanley actively dislike one another, but they are both doing their best to undermine the relationship the other has with Stella.

A Smoldering Look

            The primary sources of animosity between Blanche and Stanley are their strong personalities butting together and the blatant sexual tension between them.
            Blanche and Stella contrast each other strongly. Though Blanche considers herself classier than Stella based on the latter’s living situation, Blanche is abrasive and bold where Stella is demure and adaptable. For example, in their exchange the morning after Stanley hits Stella, Blanche says

“BLANCHE: Why! I've been half crazy, Stella! When I found out you'd been insane enough to come back in here after what happened--I started to rush in after you!
STELLA: I'm glad you didn't.
BLANCHE: What were you thinking of?
[Stella makes an indefinite gesture]
Answer me! What? What?
STELLA: Please, Blanche! Sit down and stop yelling

In this conversation, Blanche is “half-crazy”, while Stella is calm and collected, even though Stella would have full reason to be frantic as well. Stanley, on the other hand, is rough and primal, making him abrasive as well. But while Blanche maintains the illusion of southern class, Stanley is straightforward about his roughness—which probably relates to both their different upbringings and their expected gender roles. But with both of them being so brash, they make no efforts to hide their dislike of one another.


However, the relationship between Stanley and Blanche isn’t purely dislike. In his initial description, Stanley is described thusly: “Since earliest manhood the center of his life has been pleasure with women, the giving and taking of it, not with weak indulgence, dependency, but with the power and pride of a richly feathered male bird among hens” (21). Stella notes that this is at least partly why she dismisses Stanley’s violent behavior, saying “But there are things that happen between a man and a woman in the dark--that sort of make everything else seem—unimportant” (72). Blanche has been the subject of many rumors about her promiscuity, which are more likely than not true. Though Stella enjoys her sexual relationship with Stanley, she is still shy to speak of it to her sister, even though she and Stanley are married, indicating that she is not a particularly sexual person. Blanche, on the other hand, has sexuality comparable with Stanley, which is a source of the tension between them. When she Stella asks about Blanche and Stanley’s conversation, Blanche says that she was flirting with him. But there is very little in Blanche’s behavior to suggest flirting, since she talks to Stanley the same as she talks to anyone else. All of Blanche and Stanley’s “flirting” is the result of the blatant sexual tension between them, which is mostly shown through subtext. When Blanche asks Stanley to button her dress, the stage direction reads, “[He crosses through drapes with a smoldering look]” which shows his sexual interest in her.