Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Script v. Movie- A comparison for A Streetcar Named Desire

There is always a comparison towards a piece of literature with a movie that portrays the writing visually. It is almost impossible to nail all of the parts of the literature accurately because every individual has a different contraption towards the story that is being portrayed. As I watched the movie, I noticed some significant differences contrasting towards the literature. For example, the relationship between Stanley and Blanche was portrayed to be more intimate than the book explained under my interpretation. Blanche was introduced into a failing relationship as soon as she showed up unannounced at Stella’s house on Elysian Fields. The book leaves many open ends on the interpretation on the characters while the movie makes it clear and evident. The author, Tennessee Williams took a lot of effort to explain the message of the play as the way he saw it. In contrast, the movie does not portray this effort very well. The major difference that I saw between the two was the actual setting. In the movie, you can actually see the image and visual of what goes on at the bowling alley when Stanley would leave. To contrast this, the book leaves you guessing. This could be simply because it is more difficult to provide accurate visuals of the different locations on stage rather than being on camera. Another difference in the movie is the scene with the young boy and Blanche. It is portrayed in the script that the young boy is rather timid towards Blanche as she kept trying to keep him around. In the movie, the young boy has an extremely hard time keeping his eyes off of her. To conclude, this explains my statement about how Tennessee Williams wanted to explain the message and characters exactly as he wanted to. The movie fails to achieve exactly that, but the movie is not that of great difference to those who would want to simply watch the movie over reading the script.

No comments:

Post a Comment