Monday, October 27, 2014

Gender: A Social Construction

Gender isn't something we're born with it is a social construction and that is a major point Tom Franklin's story makes. From the start he isn't interested in hunting,"For some reason, I never wanted to kill things, but I wasn't bold enough to say so." This is an example of how gender is reinforced by family and friends. When he fits to the idea of how a boy and man should act he is praised and when he goes against it he is punished. Gender is not something children are born into, this is shown by Franklin's preferring dolls over hunting, "It was this kind of gift that let me know my father wanted me to hunt, though he never pressed, and let me know he was bothered by the fact that, until I was fifteen years old, I played with dolls." He is pressured to act a certain way, to live up to a standard. He feared being seen as "a pussy" and had to give up who he really was and hide his interests so he wouldn't be reprimanded. Although he says his father didn't press his ideals on him, he only praises him when he does meet the expectations of his father and otherwise he is harsh. It is very much similar to peer pressure but the pressure of not only his community but society. His situation is specific to where he grew up but there are gender expectations everywhere. His proudest moment is when he finally meets this standard and kills his first deer, he can finally be accepted into the community: "That was when everyone gathered around me, my uncles and Jeff clapping my back, Mom and my aunts hugging me, trying not to get blood on their blouses." It doesn't seem like anyone else that he looks up to really goes against performing this idea of gender so he sees it as being wrong. He isn't acting this way to fulfill what would really make him happy but everyone else. In the end he even has to continually get praise and do more it is never enough for him, he needs continual acceptance.

Dolls vs. Hunting

After reading Franklin's "Hunting Years", it was easy to see why there are so many issues with people being comfortable with their sexuality and gender identity. In his essay, masculinity is hunting. Having the strength, and stomach, and skills to hunt, is manly. His father, even as a deacon who doesn't hunt himself, tries to instill this on him. His father attempts to show him the "right" direction by recommending he buy a knife with his money, instead of another outfit for his GI Joe doll. At his school all the boys hunt, and if you don't you're labeled as inferior to those who do. It is a way to demonstrate your manhood and show that killing a living creature doesn't make you sick.

The performance of gender in Franklin's essay is done stereotypically. If you're a boy, you hunt, and if you're a girl, you play with dolls. His father seems to be worried about him because he enjoys playing with a doll more than killing animals. His mother is doing the "typical" motherly thing by telling his father to be more sympathetic.


Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Street Car Named Desire Comparisons between book and film

 After finalizing my readings of the book Street Car Named Desire  immediately after began to watch the film I notice many difference between the two. Furthermore, what i notice different between the two is that, in the book the characters are  being portrayed totally differently than from the film. Meaning in the book as I glanced through each sense as a reading I had the assumption that woman played a more dominate role than the men in the book than in the film due to how the author used particular words to describe each character giving the woman in the book more of dominant meaning than of the men. However, The author tried to make up for the lack of dominance from the male prospective by added sense will Stanley as well as the male who lives up theirs hits their wife supposedly letting them know they are in charge. In which, in the film the male dominance was a major factor moreover the women's role in the film. The male characters of the film played a even more aggressive role than the woman due to how the voices of the male characters or more aggressive and demanding than how soft and calm the woman's voice were. When reading a book the reader tries to assume what each character would sound like and only assume what is giving to them by the narrator. Whereas, in a film the person watching is actually hearing and experiencing what is going on and don't have to imagine in their minds on how each individual may look and sound like. Nevertheless, both film and the book share similar comparisons by which I can see how Mitch acts and feels about his mother and the scene from the poker night when Stanley yells Mitch's name and Mitch yells back book the book and the film showed the aggressive amongst both characters.

Cinematic Streetcar

Having read the play, watching the movie adaptation of Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire was certainly something else. Personally, I prefer reading a book or play because it allows me the freedom to cast my own characters, and picture the way I want events to play out. That's not to say I didn't like the movie, but maybe it differed from how I saw things in my mind. However, it was nice to be able to see events in action, and the ways in which characters behaved and interacted. And a lot of that has to do with the actors portraying them. I think being able to see the acting made the writing (of the play) a little more vibrant in my mind. What I did miss while watching was Williams' writing style - I like the way it flows and I find it really eloquent so for me, when it came to the movie, I really missed stage directions and scene descriptions. I even find that in his writing, Williams has a way of interjecting small, subtle nuances of character that could have perhaps been missed by the actor portraying them when they read the script and for me, when reading, those little hints stood out as very important for character development. I'm going to be honest and say that a black and white movie was hard to watch, too (even though one of my favorite movies is without color as well). But maybe that is because I was less invested in watching this depiction as I am in the one I created in my mind. I'll always be one of those people who holds to the mentality that the book - or in this case the play - is always better than the movie.

Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Music and Place.

The first difference is the inclusion of the bowling which is only referenced to in the play. There is also the addition of other scenes, although brief and possibly insignificant, like the shot of Stanley coming home from work the morning after he assaults Stella. What is accomplished in these inclusion is somewhat difficult to determine, but it is possible that some degree of significance can be attained with the consideration of the one environment that is portrayed with consistency in both the play and the film: the Kowalski's apartment.

The apartment is the center of action in both mediums. In the play the a sense of closeness is accomplished through stage direction: different characters are constantly moving in and out of a single scene which, in turn, communicates a sense of confusion and stasis. Whereas in the movie, the director, Elia Kazan, created this claustrophobic atmosphere by moving the walls of the apartment closer with each scene.

It would seem, then, that the inclusion of additional scenes outside the apartment would work against this atmosphere. But these scenes in fact lend themselves to a state of stasis through musical accompaniment. Tennessee Williams described this process in the first scene of the play: "A corresponding air is evoked by the music of Negro entertainers at a barroom around the corner. In this part of New Orleans you are practically always just around the corner, or a few doors down the street, from a tinny piano being played with the infatuated fluency of brown fingers. This "Blue Piano" expresses the spirit of the life which goes on here."

The music freezes the characters, and perhaps the city of New Orleans, by the circumstance of their socioeconomic apartments, in the distillery of the "Blue Piano."  


Imagine "A Steetcar Named Desire"

There are several differences between reading the play A Streetcar Named Desire and  watching the film. One powerful difference can be made as a mean of the imagination. Reading dialogue allows one to put his or her own interpretations in play with the story line. The imagination allows for all sorts of perspectives to be seen about the characters and plot of the story as opposed to watching the film. The film only allows one solid interpretation to be portrayed for viewers watching A Streetcar Named Desire. Films have a tendency to alter or tweak stories in a way that makes the film either more entertaining or fitting for the audience, such as the scene when Blanche screams at Mitch to go away after he tells her she would not be worthy enough to be brought home to his mother. In the book, Blanche reacts to Mitch's rejection by letting out a frightening yell, "fire!" In the film, Blanche just screams hysterically, loud enough where the whole neighborhood can hear her.
As much as the film limits one's imagination to create the story to one's understanding, the film also may help clear up any misinterpretations or blurriness about the plot and characters. Stanley, Stella's husband, we know is a rough, drunk, boisterous man who does not compromise himself for anybody. The film displays an extra emphasis on how strong Stanley's character really is: crashing things, throwing plates, yelling almost every time he speaks. While reading the play, I didn't imagine Stanley to pull such a strong mannerism in just about every scene especially when Stanley and Blanche have a dramatic outbreak while Stella is in the hospital. Stanley nearly goes mad to the point where he looks like he is about to hit Blanche across the face, which he eventually does.
Reading the play and watching the film both go hand-in-hand to compare and contrast the various perspectives about the story.

Streetcar Named Desire Book and Movie

It is always so interesting to watch a movie based on a book you've just read because you picture certain characters, and how they act and how they look. I think because Streetcar Named Desire is a play, it was always difficult to really imagine Blanche and how she really carried herself and how her mannerisms are. Vivien Leigh portrayed Blanche in such a perfect way, it makes me want to re-read the book. She brings out the traditional side Blanche wants to be so badly, but also shows how crazy Blanche really is. Marlon Brando is as genius as any of us would suspect, though I didn't picture Stanley as such a pretty boy like Brando is, he does get the role of Stanley down perfectly. The flirting was sometimes hard to catch throughout the play, but Marlon Brando really shows it with the looks he gives, and the ways he sometimes looks at Blanche. When I first pictured Stella I did not imagine Kim Hunter. I imagined Stella as a bit coyer, and more scared of Stanley than she seemed to be in the movie. 

In the movie you definitely see how much attention Blanche wants and needs from outside people, especially men. Whether it is people telling her she is pretty, or just noticing that she is there, she always makes sure she is noticed. Imaging this was a little difficult for me while reading the play, but the movie really made it clear to understand. I really enjoyed being able to understand the characters even better, and feeling like they are a little more real.