Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Not interested

"Hunting Years" was good the first few pages, but I did not like the rest. I hate hunting. I hate everything about hunting. Everything. I hate the color orange. I hate the color green. I think camo is disgusting. I have no interest in guns. I hate that killing animals is a sport. This piece was very descriptive and filled with imagery. The vivid descriptions were fine in the beginning and very disturbing for the rest. I don't want to read about how the animal bleeds and how he got blood on him and how he stabbed a deer 12 times. I hate how descriptive it was. With that being said, I think this article is a great representation of society. The guy doesn't want to hunt! But he forces himself to just so he's accepted and loved by his family. His mom was cool about his doll collection and his dad pretended to be, but it was clear he was not happy. He chose to be someone else so he wouldn't disappoint his family and be taunted by his peers. This is all because the boy wasn't interested in hunting. Although women struggle in society, men do as well. There is a lot more pressure for men to act a very specific way, and if one doesn't, he's not accepted.

The Lost Tradition

Tom Franklin comes right off the bat with a theme of masculinity in “Hunting Years.” The evidence of stereotypical masculinity is experienced throughout his writing. It reminds me of the quaint town that I grew up; where everyone hunted, everyone fished, and everyone knew each other. The stereotype of these masculine features proves to be different than any other part of the country. People fought very hard to fit in, “a boy who didn’t hunt was branded as a pussy.” is just one explanation. In a small southern community such as the wooded counties between the Alabama and Tombigee Rivers, the stereotype for masculinity is that of which you can find all across the south. People are more conservative, therefore the tradition is extremely evident.
Franklin continues to emphasize the performance of genders. The performance of males in the south differs greatly than those from up north. The scene when Franklin encounters the hunting club member on the railroad track furnishes a good example of what the men are like in this area. The members of the club explain the change that is ongoing in the south. It is not the same as it used to be and the land is seen as a recreational asset, but it really is the livelihoods of the ancestors that you used to inhabit it. The tradition is disappearing and it will continue to do so.

the performance of masculinity

The main performance of masculinity in Franklin's story is, obviously, hunting. Franklin bases this action as a right of passage into manhood handed down by his father and prescribed by the small backwoods town in Alabama he calls home. This, of course, brings about an interesting question: why hunting?

The first answer is that, traditionally, and not just within the small towns in the deep south, hunting is a man's job: the men hunt and provide food while the women stay in the house and bear children. This notion was ingrained in Franklin through familial and societal tradition: his father was "a legendary killer of turkeys" from a community of "the most seasoned woodsmen." This expectation for Franklin to perform is further manifested through the inheritance of his grandfathers shotgun, a single material object that insists adherence to tradition- "a rare Foxboro crafted of blued Sterlingworth steel."

Moreover, any attempt to reject or avoid this performance of manhood, which has been engrained by society, is, as Franklin so elegantly puts it, to be branded a "pussy." With this in consideration, Franklin seems to suggest that achieving masculinity not only equates to violence but the suppression of what society has perceived to be female characteristics- the inherently weaker sex.

But what I found to be most interesting in Franklin's story is that masculinity is only what certain people -whether that be family or society or culture or whatever- claim it to be. The best example of this can be found in the juxtaposition between the "fancy-rifled lawyer in face paint" that Franklin encounters on the railroad tracks and the Wiggins brothers from his childhood.

The latter of these are a prime example of the kind of masculinity Franklin had been expected to perform: "they were stringy, sun-yellowed boys who smelled like sweat and fish and never wore shirts or shoes in summer" (p8). Franklin, in fact, envied these boys for "the ease with which the accepted there lives, the way they spit between their teeth, flicked a rod, fired a rifle" (p9).

The man Franklin encounters on the train tracks, then, is not simply some lawyer failing to emulate masculinity: he is simply another brand in the market of masculinity's varying definition- granted a far less superior performance according to Franklin.



Gender: A Social Construction

Gender is put onto us, we are not born with it. We learn from the media, our friends, and our family the social expectations of how to act depending on what sex we are. We see this happen since the beginning of Tom Franklin's introduction when he talks about never wanting to kill anything, but being forced into hunting because he didn't want to be a "pussy." Hunting is their social expectation; it lets people know if you are actually a man, or if you're willing to be a real man. Franklin goes on to tell the reader how he preferred to play with G.I. Joe's and to please his father, and not seem like a weak boy he bought a knife instead of an outfit for he doll. This is another example of a social expectation on gender, and doing what you must to please others. Though his father said he was OK with the idea of him playing with dolls didn't change Franklin continuing to try and fit into the construction of his gender. And their excitement and proudness felt better than anything else to him. 

Of course what he must do to prove he is a man is different than other places. But we must not forget that his happens everywhere, every community, and family put expectations on boys on how to act and how to prove who they are. Or who they are suppose to be. 

Expectations of Gender

In the essay "Hunting Years," Tom Franklin goes to great length in the beginning of his writings to establish his origins. He writes about how he is from the South, Alabama to be exact, and that where he is from certain expectations are meant to be lived up to. He even emphasizes how he went to Arkansas and that doesn't truly constitute as the south. Franklin claims that in order to be a man in the South one needs to hunt animals. Hunting is associated with being a man in Franklin's south and anything less than that makes one less of a man. Franklin says that because he was 16 years old and still had yet to kill an animal he was a "pussy." Franklin doesn't even enjoy killing animals, yet he goes completely out of his way to go through the motions. He wakes up earlier than anyone else and sits in the icy cold weather to do something he doesn't even really want to do. He does it only so that he wont be perceived as a pussy to his family. To his family the proper thing for a man to do, is kill and anything less than that is unacceptable. In order to be a man in the south according to Franklin, he must go out of his way to do something that is uncomfortable to him. As a man I don't agree with this ideal, as to me being a man is standing up for ones own opinion even in the face of adversity. It's interesting that in this essay its the opposite, one must obediently sit down and say yes to what they are told to do in order to be a man. His justification being that they are from the south does not really hold water, and it seems like the standard has been set by his family more than the area he is from. It seems to be a generation thing that is passed down from one to the next. They claim it is where they are from when it is less the area they are from and more the environment of their family.

Killing A Boy's "Hart"

Mine (Colorado, 2012)
In Tom Franklin's story "Hunting Years" from his collection Poachers, masculinity is rooted in the practice of hunting. Growing up in lower Alabama, the narrator explains that boys were expected to participate in practices like hunting and fishing, and be enthusiastically interested in them, because they were normative masculine activities. Even though he didn't like it, the narrator would hunt, and began to show falsified enthusiasm for the sport. He says, "I never wanted to kill things, but I wasn't bold enough to say so," which eventually led him towards hiding his aversion by becoming "the most zealous hunter of all," because "a boy who didn't hunt was branded a pussy," (3). He explains that he "did the expected" (3), which came out of expectations born from gender roles. Growing up, he would feel guilty and foolish (2) when he made mistakes in regards to hunting and, in effect, masculinity. At one point, his gender identity is so heavily tied to hunting as masculinity that he felt ashamed for having other interests, even though they could be considered within the spectrum of masculinity, but for some reason inside his society do not - apparently a boy enjoying action figures is not the right kind of "rugged". Rather, his interest in his G.I. Joe and being able to buy it a new outfit, which would fuel his imagination, is considered too close to a feminine interest in dolls. Especially when his mother defends his desire to be imaginative to his father, the narrator feels ashamed, because he feels, on a subconscious level, that to value his G.I. Joe over a hunting knife is to be too closely aligned with feminine interests, which, with his upbringing, is wrong for a boy.
This story is interesting because it illustrates how strict gender roles can be and the confining, and really even constricting a presence they can be without being overt. It is considered monstrous in a way to o against what has been determined as normative in terms of respective gender roles and concerns.

Rigid and Strong

In society, a man is supposed to be tough, strong, an emotionally stable. In Tom Franklin's story, "Hunting Years", his portrayal of being a man does not stray too far from society's definition of a man. In the story, the protagonist grows up in a family where being a hunter means that you were a man. His brother, Jeff, and his father were both exceptional hunters, while he enjoyed playing with G.I. Joe action figures. Even though his father says that he is "...real proud..." of him, you can sense the sarcasm in his tone (Franklin 8). Also, the father tries to nudge him toward buying the hunting knife instead of things for his action figures. The reader can see that the father is happy that his son chooses the knife because he puts down ten extra dollars to help pay for it. The father relates to society's ideal man because of how tough he is, and also how he wants his son to be. Franklin also displays gender roles in his story. The parents' attitudes toward their son are that the father wants him to be tough and strong whereas the mother does not mind his playful and imaginative side. Franklin's interpretation of gender is similar to the common stereotypes of a man's a woman's attitudes toward their children.