Comparing aspects from Jim Grimsley's
Dream Boy and Tennessee Williams'
A Streetcar Named Desire.
What stood out the most to me in my reading of Grimsley's novel in relation to the other works we've read this semester was the similarities between Burke and Stanley, from Williams'
Streetcar.
Throughout each work, both Burke and Stanley both have a sense of underlying, simmering violence in their characterizations, which is displayed in a few different ways.
Both Burke and Stanley have suspicion towards each work's respective protagonist and their true nature, or the secrets they may have.
They both carry out threatening behavior towards the protagonists - Burke holds Nathan off a bridge above a river, threatening to drop him when he cant swim, and Stanley uncovers Blanche's sexual past, ruining the semblance of a life she has established for herself in New Orleans.
Both Burke and Stanley have explosive displays of violence - Burke throws Randy around, who remarks, "You always try to hurt somebody," (Grimsley, 132), which Burke eventually does, beating Nathan to death(?), as described, "as if he wants to make Nathan hurt," (Grimsley, 173). Stanley has instances of physical abuse towards his pregnant wife Stella, whom he hits.
Both Burke and Stanley display a sort of hypermasculinity within each work, which is perhaps a form of compensation for their own faults. Burke repeatedly asks after Roy's girlfriend Evelyn, and goes so far as to flaunt himself, taking off his shirt and displaying himself in the most primal way physically, asserting his masculinity. Stanley almost seems hyperbolic in his masculine characterization with displays of violence, hobbies, loudness, distrust towards Blanche (an unusual woman), and his own history - first as a veteran and then secondarily as an immigrant, which serves to alienate him as an American male, which he perhaps makes up for in a caricaturistic manner. Williams' stresses Stanley's character to make a statement about masculine behavior.
Most potently, the similarity between Burke and Stanley stems from their acts of rape within the works. Burke, who before hinted at a homoerotic subtext, bursts forth with an aggressive display of repressed sexuality upon Nathan, taking out not only his sexuality upon him, but also delivers an immense act of violence in beating him either to death or somewhere quite near it. Stanley, who has struggled to suppress Blanche's disruption of his way of life, finally acts out towards her in a catalystic way in reaction to her flirtations and seductive behavior, turning it around on her in an act of sexual violence. Both Burke and Stanley violently rip choice away from their victims, both having preyed upon them throughout the course of the works in a subtle but intent way, which finally comes to a head through an extremely savage act.
 |
| Decrepit plantation home with lots of moonlight and darkness and clouds, like in Grimsley's Dream Boy |
(Also as an unrelated side note - a thought I just had: the presence or idea of plantation homes and how they function in both works is very interesting. In
Dream Boy, obviously the "haunted" plantation home, and then in
Streetcar, the loss of Belle Reve. When reflecting on each text, the plantation house can be symbolic of a loss of, or a dilapidation of the ideals of the Old South, especially when considering how both works focus on a kind of new sexuality - either a normalcy of homosexuality or assertive female sexuality.)