Thursday, November 20, 2014
Vigil Against Street Violence
As a member of LUCAP eboard I helped with putting together this event and it turned out very well. We wanted to raise awareness of the street violence in New Orleans and make Loyola students see how often people in our neighborhood are killed and how much it affects our community. This has a lot to do with our class subject. Salvage the bones is a very good example of how poverty can affect how a child is brought up. We see them fighting dogs, fighting themselves, an alcoholic father, and young pregnancy. There were some kids from the Anna's Arts for Kids program and they are being affected currently by having to grow up in these bad areas. They are in failing schools and it is much harder for them socially and economically to have good opportunities. It also shows that racism and many other issues we've talked about in class are still very prevalent in today's society. I'm currently reading Jesmyn Ward's "Men We Reaped" which is a memoir about the many young black men she has known that were murdered. When I went to see Jesmyn Ward speak she talked about how the place to start with fixing these issues is discussion and tat is what we aimed for at the vigil: acknowledging these issues and bringing it to the attention of the more fortunate members of the community. I learned a lot from the multiple speakers and Father Bill who was the leader of the ceremony said we all have power to help resolve this issue. He said it's the process of helping things progress rather than trying to fix everything all at once. He also makes a yearly murder board for New Orleans which made the problem and people affected very real. Overall it was a great and powerful experience and connected back to this class very well.
The victims: Blanche and Nathan
Blanche from A Streetcar Named Desire and Nathan have many of the same obstacles even though their characters are very different. Both are raped and must decide if they are to tell what has happened to them or not. For Blanche she does tell and ends up in a mental asylum, so for her telling the truth didn't seem to end up being the "right choice." For Nathan he has not told and is also keeping his sexuality a secret but it is not helping him either because he is stuck with his family; his father who is the abuser and his mother who stands by and does not help or abuses by neglecting him. Also, both Blanche and Nathan are financially dependent on their abusers. Nathan who is a minor will have nowhere to turn unless he does out his abuser. While, Blanche has brought herself to financial ruin and comes to seek the help of her sister and by default Stanley. They are in different time periods as well as opposite genders which also affects how they will be treated. Both although victims can be seen as at fault or bad victims. Blanche is also a perpetrator herself on young boys so it is hard to sympathize with her. Nathan, because he lives in such a religious and small town and is gay, could be exposed and seen as also taking part in these sinful acts or deserving it. It is interesting that their stories are so different but they struggle with the same things.
Today's Vigil
Today at St. Anna's Episcopal Church, Liza organized an amazing vigil against urban violence. We took a bus to the church, and were greeted by Rev. William Terry. Rev. Terry lead us through prayers honoring those who have fallen victim to urban violence, and we sang hymns together. He spoke on his personal experiences in the area of the ruthless crimes he has witnessed, but also had three children, and a mother whose son was a victim of the violence speak. The children told stories of their experiences living in the neighborhood, and what their dreams were for the future.
The whole congregation was very moving. There was a strong sense of community and will to find ways to keep the coming generations out of the seemingly endless cycle of urban violence.
The vigil ended with a candle-lighting, and the names of those who passed were read aloud and honored.
Stella & Nathan's Mom
When looking at Williams' "A Streetcar Named Desire", and Grimsley's "Dream Boy", there are several common themes. One of the most prominent shared themes is the similarity of Stella and Nathan's mom's roles as enablers.
In "A Streetcar Named Desire", Stella is described as weak almost. She knows that Stanley's abuse is wrong, but chooses not to do anything about it. She knows that he loathes Blanche, but she chooses to still believe him over her when the rape is committed because it is easier. She chooses to remain ignorant of his actions because it will not disrupt the life that she has grown accustomed to living
In "Dream Boy", Nathan's mom plays the same role. She is described by Nathan as being invisible. She knows very well what goes on between her son and her husband, but makes a choice not to do anything about it because it would mean uprooting the life she has grown comfortable with. She instead allows it to happen, without stepping in and saving her son from a disgusting situation.
Both are enablers. They understand that the weaker party needs help and someone to stand up for them, but they are too worried about what their support would mean for them. Their support would likely change the situation they've grown comfortable in. They would lose the figure that they rely on for support, their husbands.
In "A Streetcar Named Desire", Stella is described as weak almost. She knows that Stanley's abuse is wrong, but chooses not to do anything about it. She knows that he loathes Blanche, but she chooses to still believe him over her when the rape is committed because it is easier. She chooses to remain ignorant of his actions because it will not disrupt the life that she has grown accustomed to living
In "Dream Boy", Nathan's mom plays the same role. She is described by Nathan as being invisible. She knows very well what goes on between her son and her husband, but makes a choice not to do anything about it because it would mean uprooting the life she has grown comfortable with. She instead allows it to happen, without stepping in and saving her son from a disgusting situation.
Both are enablers. They understand that the weaker party needs help and someone to stand up for them, but they are too worried about what their support would mean for them. Their support would likely change the situation they've grown comfortable in. They would lose the figure that they rely on for support, their husbands.
A History of Violence
Comparing aspects from Jim Grimsley's Dream Boy and Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire.
What stood out the most to me in my reading of Grimsley's novel in relation to the other works we've read this semester was the similarities between Burke and Stanley, from Williams' Streetcar.
Throughout each work, both Burke and Stanley both have a sense of underlying, simmering violence in their characterizations, which is displayed in a few different ways.
Both Burke and Stanley have suspicion towards each work's respective protagonist and their true nature, or the secrets they may have.
They both carry out threatening behavior towards the protagonists - Burke holds Nathan off a bridge above a river, threatening to drop him when he cant swim, and Stanley uncovers Blanche's sexual past, ruining the semblance of a life she has established for herself in New Orleans.
Both Burke and Stanley have explosive displays of violence - Burke throws Randy around, who remarks, "You always try to hurt somebody," (Grimsley, 132), which Burke eventually does, beating Nathan to death(?), as described, "as if he wants to make Nathan hurt," (Grimsley, 173). Stanley has instances of physical abuse towards his pregnant wife Stella, whom he hits.
Both Burke and Stanley display a sort of hypermasculinity within each work, which is perhaps a form of compensation for their own faults. Burke repeatedly asks after Roy's girlfriend Evelyn, and goes so far as to flaunt himself, taking off his shirt and displaying himself in the most primal way physically, asserting his masculinity. Stanley almost seems hyperbolic in his masculine characterization with displays of violence, hobbies, loudness, distrust towards Blanche (an unusual woman), and his own history - first as a veteran and then secondarily as an immigrant, which serves to alienate him as an American male, which he perhaps makes up for in a caricaturistic manner. Williams' stresses Stanley's character to make a statement about masculine behavior.
Most potently, the similarity between Burke and Stanley stems from their acts of rape within the works. Burke, who before hinted at a homoerotic subtext, bursts forth with an aggressive display of repressed sexuality upon Nathan, taking out not only his sexuality upon him, but also delivers an immense act of violence in beating him either to death or somewhere quite near it. Stanley, who has struggled to suppress Blanche's disruption of his way of life, finally acts out towards her in a catalystic way in reaction to her flirtations and seductive behavior, turning it around on her in an act of sexual violence. Both Burke and Stanley violently rip choice away from their victims, both having preyed upon them throughout the course of the works in a subtle but intent way, which finally comes to a head through an extremely savage act.
(Also as an unrelated side note - a thought I just had: the presence or idea of plantation homes and how they function in both works is very interesting. In Dream Boy, obviously the "haunted" plantation home, and then in Streetcar, the loss of Belle Reve. When reflecting on each text, the plantation house can be symbolic of a loss of, or a dilapidation of the ideals of the Old South, especially when considering how both works focus on a kind of new sexuality - either a normalcy of homosexuality or assertive female sexuality.)
What stood out the most to me in my reading of Grimsley's novel in relation to the other works we've read this semester was the similarities between Burke and Stanley, from Williams' Streetcar.
Throughout each work, both Burke and Stanley both have a sense of underlying, simmering violence in their characterizations, which is displayed in a few different ways.
Both Burke and Stanley have suspicion towards each work's respective protagonist and their true nature, or the secrets they may have.
They both carry out threatening behavior towards the protagonists - Burke holds Nathan off a bridge above a river, threatening to drop him when he cant swim, and Stanley uncovers Blanche's sexual past, ruining the semblance of a life she has established for herself in New Orleans.
Both Burke and Stanley have explosive displays of violence - Burke throws Randy around, who remarks, "You always try to hurt somebody," (Grimsley, 132), which Burke eventually does, beating Nathan to death(?), as described, "as if he wants to make Nathan hurt," (Grimsley, 173). Stanley has instances of physical abuse towards his pregnant wife Stella, whom he hits.
Both Burke and Stanley display a sort of hypermasculinity within each work, which is perhaps a form of compensation for their own faults. Burke repeatedly asks after Roy's girlfriend Evelyn, and goes so far as to flaunt himself, taking off his shirt and displaying himself in the most primal way physically, asserting his masculinity. Stanley almost seems hyperbolic in his masculine characterization with displays of violence, hobbies, loudness, distrust towards Blanche (an unusual woman), and his own history - first as a veteran and then secondarily as an immigrant, which serves to alienate him as an American male, which he perhaps makes up for in a caricaturistic manner. Williams' stresses Stanley's character to make a statement about masculine behavior.
Most potently, the similarity between Burke and Stanley stems from their acts of rape within the works. Burke, who before hinted at a homoerotic subtext, bursts forth with an aggressive display of repressed sexuality upon Nathan, taking out not only his sexuality upon him, but also delivers an immense act of violence in beating him either to death or somewhere quite near it. Stanley, who has struggled to suppress Blanche's disruption of his way of life, finally acts out towards her in a catalystic way in reaction to her flirtations and seductive behavior, turning it around on her in an act of sexual violence. Both Burke and Stanley violently rip choice away from their victims, both having preyed upon them throughout the course of the works in a subtle but intent way, which finally comes to a head through an extremely savage act.
![]() |
| Decrepit plantation home with lots of moonlight and darkness and clouds, like in Grimsley's Dream Boy |
(Also as an unrelated side note - a thought I just had: the presence or idea of plantation homes and how they function in both works is very interesting. In Dream Boy, obviously the "haunted" plantation home, and then in Streetcar, the loss of Belle Reve. When reflecting on each text, the plantation house can be symbolic of a loss of, or a dilapidation of the ideals of the Old South, especially when considering how both works focus on a kind of new sexuality - either a normalcy of homosexuality or assertive female sexuality.)
Reflection
Jim Grimsley's "Dream Boy" is captivating. The novel brings in so many forbidden elements that the reader can't put the book down. It is filled with suspense, from Nathan's fathers mysterious past, to the lingering tension that constantly fills the space between Nathan and Roy.
Nathan's family's past is filled with unknown variables. It is never outwardly said but we can very obviously infer that Nathan's father molests him. His mother is an enabler. She is invisible, and does not do anything to stop his father. It leave the reader on constant edge, wondering when and if it will happen again, and how it will effect his relationship with Roy. Personally, I want to know why they keep moving. Did people find out what goes on in their house?
Roy and Nathan bring a new twist on the classic tale of forbidden love. Their role as secretly gay lovers in the south captivate the audience. Combined with Roy's constant anxiety that someone may find them out, Nathan's issues that have arisen from his relationship with his dad are overwhelming. Roy flip-flops everyday. One day he seems to be totally devoted and in love with Nathan, and then he goes to completely ignoring him.
Nathan's family's past is filled with unknown variables. It is never outwardly said but we can very obviously infer that Nathan's father molests him. His mother is an enabler. She is invisible, and does not do anything to stop his father. It leave the reader on constant edge, wondering when and if it will happen again, and how it will effect his relationship with Roy. Personally, I want to know why they keep moving. Did people find out what goes on in their house?
Roy and Nathan bring a new twist on the classic tale of forbidden love. Their role as secretly gay lovers in the south captivate the audience. Combined with Roy's constant anxiety that someone may find them out, Nathan's issues that have arisen from his relationship with his dad are overwhelming. Roy flip-flops everyday. One day he seems to be totally devoted and in love with Nathan, and then he goes to completely ignoring him.
Fergusons Across America
After attending the panel discussion about the situation in Ferguson, Missouri put on by Ms. Boyett on Tuesday, I feel like I have a much broader understanding of the issues. Each of the six speakers shared there opinions on different aspects of the situation resulting in a well rounded, incredibly informational discussion addressing all the "whys" that have arisen after the shooting.
My favorite speaker discussed why violence is an issue in the first place. People are not violent because of their color, people are violent because of the imbalance that plagues our society. I couldn't agree with her more. Individuals act out when they feel like they aren't receiving the dignity they deserve, which is what is currently happening in Ferguson. Both the victims and the activists deserve respect, and they deserve to be heard - not just shut down. We need balance in our society, and we need the return of community.
Another one of my favorites from the panel discussed the huge role social media has played in unfolding the injustices happening in Ferguson. It has facilitated open speaking, and non censored discussion. People are able to get news from sources in the area themselves, without the filters and distortion the media often puts forth. The case has gotten worldwide support from the global community thanks the speed on the internet.
I also thought what the police chief had to say was interesting. He highlighted the manipulation through misinformation occurring in major media outlets. It had become a race for stations to release the story first, not release a reliable story, and people are believing media distortion to be the absolute truth.
Now the question is what do we need to do as a community now to help prevent cases drowning in injustice, as is happening currently in Missouri.
My favorite speaker discussed why violence is an issue in the first place. People are not violent because of their color, people are violent because of the imbalance that plagues our society. I couldn't agree with her more. Individuals act out when they feel like they aren't receiving the dignity they deserve, which is what is currently happening in Ferguson. Both the victims and the activists deserve respect, and they deserve to be heard - not just shut down. We need balance in our society, and we need the return of community.
Another one of my favorites from the panel discussed the huge role social media has played in unfolding the injustices happening in Ferguson. It has facilitated open speaking, and non censored discussion. People are able to get news from sources in the area themselves, without the filters and distortion the media often puts forth. The case has gotten worldwide support from the global community thanks the speed on the internet.
I also thought what the police chief had to say was interesting. He highlighted the manipulation through misinformation occurring in major media outlets. It had become a race for stations to release the story first, not release a reliable story, and people are believing media distortion to be the absolute truth.
Now the question is what do we need to do as a community now to help prevent cases drowning in injustice, as is happening currently in Missouri.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
