It is evident from the first time
we hear about Manny from Esch, that she has a crush on him. When she first
becomes aware of his arrival to The Pit in the story, she mentions that the
sight of him “breaks the cocoon of her rib cage and makes her heart want to
fly.” As the chapter progresses the feelings she experiences for him become
more prominent. During her internal monologues, her thoughts always turn to
Manny. So much so that even with multiple obstacles in her way, like her dads
truck being parked by the front door or Junior hitting her in the leg with a
shine bottle, she still looks at Manny first. Even when she accidently cuts
herself after dropping a bottle her thoughts first go to Manny, worrying about
him seeing her act vulnerable. She even
refers to Manny as “Gold” at one point. Esch is clearly desperate for Manny and
will do anything to have him. She does not have a real relationship with Manny
that isn’t a physical one. When around his friends, Manny barely speaks to
Esch. Even when they are together physically he will not kiss her, which is
arguably one of the most intimate moments a couple can have.
Her desperate desire to have Manny
clouds her judgment. She gives herself to him and many other boys in a futile
attempt to experience love. It is clear
that she is trying to emulate the Greek Mythology book that she has been
reading. She even refers to how Manny loves her like Jason. Jason was a hero of
Greek Mythology, the leader of the
Argonauts and lover to the Sorceress Medea. To have a passionate love that
lasts through the ages is her goal. She is so desperate to love Manny that she
never for a moment stops to think about what Manny’s thoughts on the matter
are. She is insistent on creating a relationship in her mind, that doesn’t exist,
just so that she can experience some kind of “love.”
When I first read the chapter I though the same as you, that Esch was obsessing too much and she needed to put her focus somewhere else. As I have thought more about it, I have realized that we need to remember where she is in her life. Though she and her family are in extreme circumstances, or at least they will be soon, we must remember her age. Esch is a teenage girl with teenage hormones and feelings. Lets think back to when we were younger and all we thought about was if the person we liked would say hi to us, or even just look our way. Esch believes she is in love, and at her age, and with her strong feelings, she may be. Even if Manny does not feel the exact same way. If this love helps her survive the storm that is coming, then maybe that is exactly how she should be feeling.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree that Esch is obsessing over a guy who hardly acknowledges her outside of sex. To cope with her reality and familial circumstances, which is far from perfect, she seems to find an escape in becoming these Greek goddesses in her mind. She's just a young girl creating a sort of comfort zone or a feel-good-about-herself thing in the Greek goddesses. Maybe she feels weak , inadequate or incapable and less than spectacular. We don't get a chance to see her outlook on life outside of Manny really (at least not yet), but it's probably a bleak outlook. Considering that the Greek goddesses were these powerful forces who demanded acknowledgement, I guess I can see how these characters would serve as inspiration to a young girl who probably feels a lil slapped around by life. I believe she blocks out reality and dreams up a sort of alternate reality in which Manny adores her and in which her life is more exciting. (I'm not judging, just witnessing)
ReplyDelete