Thursday, September 4, 2014

How Gender (or Being Female) Affects Esch


In Bois Sauvage, Esch is justified in feeling “alone as the only girl” because of the ways her gender has affected her life, and the sorts of expectations that are imposed upon her because of it. Certainly Esch isn’t literally the only girl, but she is the only one facing the sorts of predicaments that she does in the course of Salvage the Bones. And while expectations based on gender don’t make an overt appearance in the novel, they are still present in undertones of language or in the actions of the male characters.
Specifically regarding Esch and at the way that gender works in her life, it is important to examine the ways in which she interacts with the males around her, and how those relationships influence the ways that gender roles are portrayed in her life. But it is also important to study in regards to the gender expectations imposed on Esch the ways in which other females may shape the way she view her gender and her roles because of it.
Esch suffers from self-esteem issues seen throughout the course of the novel so far that occur internally having to do with both her physicality and the way she carries herself. Manny’s girlfriend has a huge effect on Esch in regards to femininity, because she has Manny’s “love” where Esch does not. That is a point of contention with Esch in terms of her own womanhood. Esch is willing to give Manny whatever he wants, even if it is detrimental to her own well-being, because as a female, she thinks that that is the way to obtain the affection of a man. The most influential woman Esch ever had in her life was her mother, who she lost when she was young. All that Esch has to influence the role her gender takes on in terms of womanly behavior are the things her mother did, or the lessons her mother taught her and her brothers.
That being said, Esch’s role amongst the men in her family is slightly muted, with her being the only girl. There is a presence of sibling love, as friends, but certainly as caretakers also. Esch remains outside of the circle of her brothers and their friends because of her sex; she cannot be fully included like one of them because of her otherness. While her brothers love her – see, Randall’s treatment of her cut hand, or Skeetah’s concern as he suspects her pregnancy – the brother’s friends have used her body for sex.
Which leads to the role Manny’s relationship with Esch, which is really more of a manipulation, has on Esch’s view of her expectations as a female. As society has objectified women, so too does Manny with Esch. He reduces her to nothing but a sexual object and ignores her completely as a person outside of their private interactions in which he uses her.

2 comments:

  1. This post thoroughly examines Esch and how being a female has made her experience at the Pit completely different from those of her brothers, as well as their friends. I agree in the sense that she is a muted because of her gender, and her self esteem issues are prominent throughout the novel. However, I don't agree with what you states that, "Esch is willing to give Manny whatever he wants, even if it is detrimental to her own well-being, because as a female, she thinks that that is the way to obtain the affection of a man". I think that she knows giving a man everything isn't the best way to attract him, because of the way she spoke about her mom and dad meeting. She is aware that what she is doing will probably be completely fruitless, however she loves him so much that she doesn't care. I do agree with you that the relationship is incredibly manipulative. He takes advantage of the fact she is so willing to give herself to him.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While I think you're making good points, Alexandra, I agree more with Rosie's ideas about Esch's behavior. Though I think she definitely understands on some level that her efforts are fruitless, she doesn't seem to think that they will continue to be fruitless. She asks herself why Manny won't look at her as if someday he will look at her, when he probably will not, somewhat figuratively speaking. She seems to think that Manny should love her but just doesn't right now, when its entirely possible that he could never love her. Even knowing that she is pregnant with his child and having no real options, she still just focuses on wanting Manny to look at her when she's around him, even though this pregnancy is 1) detrimental to her well-being at this point and 2) probably the more important thing to focus on in terms of Manny.

    ReplyDelete