Thursday, November 20, 2014

The victims: Blanche and Nathan

Blanche from A Streetcar Named Desire and Nathan have many of the same obstacles even though their characters are very different. Both are raped and must decide if they are to tell what has happened to them or not. For Blanche she does tell and ends up in a mental asylum, so for her telling the truth didn't seem to end up being the "right choice." For Nathan he has not told and is also keeping his sexuality a secret but it is not helping him either because he is stuck with his family; his father who is the abuser and his mother who stands by and does not help or abuses by neglecting him. Also, both Blanche and Nathan are financially dependent on their abusers. Nathan who is a minor will have nowhere to turn unless he does out his abuser. While, Blanche has brought herself to financial ruin and comes to seek the help of her sister and by default Stanley. They are in different time periods as well as opposite genders which also affects how they will be treated.  Both although victims can be seen as at fault or bad victims. Blanche is also a perpetrator herself on young boys so it is hard to sympathize with her. Nathan, because he lives in such a religious and small town and is gay, could be exposed and seen as also taking part in these sinful acts or deserving it. It is interesting that their stories are so different but they struggle with the same things.

1 comment:

  1. You make a very good point about how both Blanche and Nathan could be seen unsympathetically if they told people what has happened to them. Its interesting to think about Blanche as both a victim of rape and a perpetrator of statutory rape, making the her morality dubious to the other characters in the story.

    ReplyDelete