Tuesday, October 14, 2014
Streetcar Named Desire Book and Movie Comparison
After reading a book and then watching the movie right after the book, one can notice several differences between the two. Between the book and the movie of A Streetcar Named Desire , there are numerous differences. One thing that the movie portrays well that the book does not is the actual acting of the characters. The movie shows the emotions and feelings that the characters show whereas reading the book, the audience has to interpret the feelings of the characters themselves. The same thing goes with the setting. Readers picture each scene with only a description given by the author. But by watching the movie, the audience can visualize the scene in its entirety. However, in the movie, some scenes were either altered slightly, greatly, or additional dialogue was added. For example, when Blanche was arguing with Mitch, the book's version had her yelling out "Fire" while in the movie, she simply yelled very loudly. Also, during the same scene in the movie, there was extended dialogue after Mitch ran off. Although the book and movie ran parallel to each other, each of them can give their audiences different views about how the overall story is told.
Script v. Movie- A comparison for A Streetcar Named Desire
There is always a comparison towards a piece of literature with a movie that portrays the writing visually. It is almost impossible to nail all of the parts of the literature accurately because every individual has a different contraption towards the story that is being portrayed. As I watched the movie, I noticed some significant differences contrasting towards the literature. For example, the relationship between Stanley and Blanche was portrayed to be more intimate than the book explained under my interpretation. Blanche was introduced into a failing relationship as soon as she showed up unannounced at Stella’s house on Elysian Fields. The book leaves many open ends on the interpretation on the characters while the movie makes it clear and evident. The author, Tennessee Williams took a lot of effort to explain the message of the play as the way he saw it. In contrast, the movie does not portray this effort very well. The major difference that I saw between the two was the actual setting. In the movie, you can actually see the image and visual of what goes on at the bowling alley when Stanley would leave. To contrast this, the book leaves you guessing. This could be simply because it is more difficult to provide accurate visuals of the different locations on stage rather than being on camera. Another difference in the movie is the scene with the young boy and Blanche. It is portrayed in the script that the young boy is rather timid towards Blanche as she kept trying to keep him around. In the movie, the young boy has an extremely hard time keeping his eyes off of her. To conclude, this explains my statement about how Tennessee Williams wanted to explain the message and characters exactly as he wanted to. The movie fails to achieve exactly that, but the movie is not that of great difference to those who would want to simply watch the movie over reading the script.
Streetcar movie vs book
The movie and book have many similarities Movie Blanche is very dramatic and almost as hard to understand as book Blanche. She is always irrational and begging for attention. I did not expect the character who plays Stella, I'm not really sure what I expected, but actress Kim Hunter was not what I expected. The movie really shows what a character Blanche. Towards the end you can see how hysterical and pathological she is. It's much easier to follow the storyline when people are performing it it. Blanche definitely seems to have some sort of mental instability and it's clear in the end that everyone when she gets taken that everyone around her realizes it. I liked the movie and book in different ways. I enjoyed the book because I could interpret in my own way and create my own character personalities. I liked watching the movie because it was less ambiguous and more interesting at some parts.
Steetcar: The Movie
There
is something to be said about watching a movie based on a written play/book.
With Streetcar, the movie really
served to bring all of the characters to life in a way that the written work
didn’t completely convey. The movie gave faces to all the characters that we
had only read about. In the movie, a few things came across that didn’t while I
was reading. Blanche and Stanley’s relationship was a lot flirtier than I
initially picked up on in the written play. While it was obvious that there was
a little bit of flirting, the movie really showed the complicated dynamic
between Blanche and Stanley. When watching the movie, I felt that Blanche was a
much more likeable person compared to in the book, even though the lines were
completely the same. The movie also shed light on the nuances of Stella and
Stanley’s relationship. While Stella is portrayed as the strong, stable and straightforward
sister, her interactions with Stanley show her weaknesses. Stella is more
socially acceptable because she’s a simple housewife, taking care of her
husband and fulfilling wifely duties. Blanche, however, being single and
promiscuous, is stigmatized by society. The movie really shows that Blanche may
not be the attention-seeking, drama queen that she is treated as. On the
contrary, she may incite resentment in Stanley because Blanche acts
independently without taking orders from any man. When Blanche enters Stanley
and Stella’s lives, she becomes the observer. Through Blanche, the audience
learns that Stella and Stanley’s relationship is ultimately dysfunctional as
they fight and make up at the drop of a hat. The movie really shows how Blanche
became the scapegoat for everything that went wrong between Stella and Stanley,
even though the two likely had problems long before Blanche ever showed up.
Sunday, October 5, 2014
Blanche and Stanley
I think the source of Blanche's animosity derives from her early lifestyle compared to her current lifestyle. She is used to a wealthy lifestyle and everything coming easy to her. She and her sister, Stella, used to live in a comfortable plantation house, but now, they have lost the plantation house and are barely able to support themselves. Blanche is having a hard time adjusting to living off the land while Stella on the other hand is content with living in a small apartment with a Polish immigrant as her husband. The hostility that Blanche has towards Stella comes from Stella's ability to be able to live comfortably in conditions that she did not grow up in; yet, Blanche is critical towards Stella for this reason.
Stanley, on the other hand, has a male-dominant personality. He thinks that because he is a man, he is entitled to everything his wife has, and he is able to establish dominance over her. He also does not return any of the affection that Stella shows to him because his male mindset makes him see Stella as only a woman; not the woman that he swore his "love" to.
Stanley, on the other hand, has a male-dominant personality. He thinks that because he is a man, he is entitled to everything his wife has, and he is able to establish dominance over her. He also does not return any of the affection that Stella shows to him because his male mindset makes him see Stella as only a woman; not the woman that he swore his "love" to.
Stella vs. Blanche
The animosity between Blanche and Stella is very evident throughout the play. The pair are sisters, who grew up in an upper-class childhood, on a plantation called Belle Reave. Now, Stella lives in New Orleans, where people don't mind getting a little dirty, and Blanche comes to live her her after losing their plantation. The two main sources of animosity between the pair are Stella's living conditions, and Stanley. Stella, although Blanche's little sister, has always felt like the eldest - and Blanche isn't fast at clarifying. Blanche is a high maintenance, dependent, dramatic, and constantly needs her ego patted. Stella is more docile, she willingly jumps when Blanche tells her to, and constantly reassures her of her beauty and grace - however, when she begins to fire at her burly husband, Stanley, Stella begins to loose her tolerance.
Blanche does not approve whatsoever of Stanley, although she uses every opportunity she can at the beginning to flirt with him. She thinks he is a brute, and she not only can't stand to live with them, but also doesn't hide the fact that she doesn't think Stella should be with him. However, Stella is head over heels for him, and looks past his roughness with her, especially when he drinks.
Blanche also constantly hounds on Stella for her living conditions. She very obviously does not like New Orleans and its different, rambunctious atmosphere. She is still bitter about Stella leaving Belle Reave. However, Stella clearly loves where she's at, and who she is surrounded by. Tension fills the air whenever Blanche suggests the two leave and go somewhere different.
Blanche does not approve whatsoever of Stanley, although she uses every opportunity she can at the beginning to flirt with him. She thinks he is a brute, and she not only can't stand to live with them, but also doesn't hide the fact that she doesn't think Stella should be with him. However, Stella is head over heels for him, and looks past his roughness with her, especially when he drinks.
Blanche also constantly hounds on Stella for her living conditions. She very obviously does not like New Orleans and its different, rambunctious atmosphere. She is still bitter about Stella leaving Belle Reave. However, Stella clearly loves where she's at, and who she is surrounded by. Tension fills the air whenever Blanche suggests the two leave and go somewhere different.
Blanche is a Wrench
There are numerous sources for Stanley’s animosity towards Blanche.
First, Stanley is upset by Blanche’s surprise arrival. Further, Blanche’s
‘badittude’ really gets under Stanley’s skin. Stanley is a manly man and likely
used to being in control of a situation. When Blanche shows up, unannounced,
there is nothing that Stanley can do about it. Blanche has a “holier than thou”
attitude, possibly stemming from the lavish lifestyle she is used to leading.
Her attitude does not mesh well with Stanley’s blue-collar way of life. In
addition, Blanche is a beggar in this scenario and she is trying to be a
chooser. She constantly insults the way that Stella and Stanley live in such a
small space. It seems that there is a large conflict in values between Stanley
and Blanche. Blanche believes that
luxury is a necessity, while Stanley believes that luxury is superfluous. The
dynamic between Stella and Blanche is interesting, as well. Stella seems to
have values more aligned with her husband than with her sister. Stanley is
probably annoyed that Stella defends Blanche instead of taking his side out
right. Therefore, Stella’s relationship with her sister causes tension in
Stella and Stanley’s marriage. Stanley continually blames Blanche for her
current circumstances, making Stanley seem pretty insensitive. However, Blanche
doesn’t make it easy to feel compassion for her. Clearly, Blanche is a monkey
wrench in Stella and Stanley’s marriage.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)